This, I like...
The graphics are somewhat lacking. Don't get me wrong, there are some great effects and surfaces in there, but a lot of it seems to be cut off short, like something more could have been added. This goes for the audio-track as well. All in all, it looks as though this game needs about six more months in the cooker.
The storyline has something rarely found in over-ambitious games; a great foundation followed by a hollow feeling of disappointment. Oftentimes, it'll be the other way around; a weak baseline hidden behind amazing effects and stereotypical dialogue. This is not the case with Caribbean Tales - the story does contain a lot of substance, all you need to do, is allow yourself to delve into it.
This may take some imagination, but come on - how hard could it be? Just last Sunday, my niece said to me: "Did you know Santa has a red bottom?" and she's only five years old! :-P
Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed..!