Im not so sure
Game play - relatively unchanged from call of duty two, although there was the addition of the close fight mechanic which mirrors resident evil 4's. the fight mechanic is quite bland and uneventful and just makes me wish they hadn't put it in the game. My one big pet peeve is even when i am behind cover that i get hit, many people like those at www.gametrailers.com in their official review have said that some peices of cover have no collision detection. no collision detection i a ww2 game much less a next-gen game. the online modes are relatively fun but for me it was hard to get used to because just as in the single player you cannot really tell your foes from your allies other than in multi player the people have ranks above their head but if you arent paying attention it does get annoying. Graphics - The graphics do look very good on the characters, as for the scenery they do look a little bland all the plants and things are 2d images which doesnt bother me much but it would be nice to see some polish on a next-gen game. although the character models do look good they come down with a bit of eq2 syndrome in looking like they are doll like, almost like something you would buy at a GI joe store.
Sound - Most of the weapon sounds remain unchanged from Cod2 to Cod3 so these are relatively good. The voice acting on the other hand is very bland and predictable, they could have done way better in this area.
Value - The game takes about 10 hours to complete which is an average length for a game of this day and age, its no oblivion in terms of length. The multi player is where anyone will have the bulk of their fun so if your not much of an online player you will be disappointed. The single player though of average length is relatively uneventful and even on some of the easier difficulties can be frustrating at parts and certain battles. It can be especially frustrating when you are doing the achievement grind.
To conclude this review the game could have been alot better, it is still a good game but no where near where Cod 1 and 2 were. Get it for the Battlefield type online modes