FUN
Sound: the weapons all sound pretty good. bullets flying and the old western weaponry sound pretty cool. the voice acting is pretty well done, except an occasional over the top voice here and there. the music is also very atmospheric and fitting, although i turned it off to have a more realistic experience. - 8.5
Gameplay: mixed feelings on this one. the gun gameplay when you play as reverend ray is pretty solid. the 360 controller works well with the action. the concentration mode works well with the analog sticks of the 360 controller. the game also runs pretty much smooth all the way through. now where the gameplay can be frustrating is when you play as billy candle. i found myself running around for 10 minutes with no clue what to do in some parts of the game. at times, the game doesnt direct you good enough so that you know what you are supposed to do. also, some of the climbing mechanics can be kind of annoying, and i found myself falling to my death frequently. - 7.5
Value: what can i say, this game is fun. i rented it and returned it the next day. i beat the game in that amount of time. dont get me wrong, the game is too terribly short, i just played it a lot. i would say it would take about 10 hours for the average first person shooter fan to beat the first time they play through it. 8.0
tilt: the game does have some staying power. some of the missions were a lot of fun, especially the reverend ray ones. i could see myself renting the game again. now i didnt get a chance to play the multiplayer, because my internet was messed up at the time, but i hear its pretty fun. based on the gameplay from the single player i think that multiplayer would work quite well. - 8.0