My 1st impressions after beating Portrait of Ruin. While it has a lot of replay value, PoR is just more of the same.
I also have to wonder why Dracula was really involved with this game, the story didn't really call for it, and frankly I would have loved to see Charlotte and Jonathan just travel the world rather than thru portraits. Its fun going to places other than Dracula's castle for once, and PoR really did bring that part out. However, all these segments do end up suffering in lack of detail or exploration and in turn make Dracula's castle the same. There isn't much detail in either sections due to trying too hard to deliver two things at once to players when really they should have focused on one or the other. I didn't feel like I was exploring Dracula's castle once again, but rather just jumping from point A in the overworld, and finding point B in it only to do the same thing I did in A, but in a different location. Also save points were often scattered far too much and that tended to make the game annoying when exploring newer areas. But not everything is all bad, once you beat the game you're reward with tons of new stuff to play with, like the sisters mode, cap levels, hard mode, boss challenge, and a bunch of other cool stuff. It can at least be said that Portrait of Ruin does deliver content and for that I admire it. I can't say Portrait of Ruin is my favorite Castlevania game, but it's far from the worse.
Conclusion:
Portrait of Ruin really could have been better if we didn't actually return to Dracula's castle. However, that is not the case, and while it's not a bad game, a lot of potential was missed. Still, Portrait of Ruin offers a lot to players, and I think if you're even remotely interested in Castlevania you will have fun with this game.