Good: Scary :) Innovating, Graphics, great fighting Bad: Short, confusing story
The game was actually kinda scary, much more than I thought it was gonna be. After playing Doom 3 I tought the whole horror genre was dying. The popup monsters actually scared me this time.
But there are two things that bothers me, two big things. One the game was way to short, I played it through in one six hour sitting, that was far under my expectations. And second WTF what happened to the story?
If you find it in a Bargain Bag buy it, i just got it for a reasonable price tag and it was worth a play through, maybe just a rent. Not much of replay value.