It's the best game on the XBOX 360, but it still has flaws.
Now, on to the good stuff. If you take the time to master a character, it can be very rewarding and my friend tells me online play is some of the most fun stuff out there. The character models may not look that good, but there have been improvements, no matter how small. The new characters (except Spartan) are quite fun and useful. Brad Wong is one of the greatest fighting game characters ever. Kokoro, the Geisha-in-training’s costumes could use some work (unless that’s traditional geisha attire) but she is a good character when mastered. The FMV in this game is beautiful. In Kasumi’s ending scene, if you can take your eyes off of her, the fish looks beautiful, the coral is grand . . . but as far as I can tell she has two right hands in the final scene. Some of these scenes, however, are downright hilarious, like Brad’s Genra Trip (like a kaleidoscopic acid trip on wine) and Zack’s treasure-hunting with Nikki. The final ending, Helena’s, is a movie to rival the best of Final Fantasy and is moving and emotional and downright beautiful and well-executed. It’s worth buying the game just to see some of the ending movies. The reversal system is vastly reworked, making the game much less defensive-based and more balanced. It also makes it challenging for defensive players like myself who are used to being able to win a fight by using series of reversals.
The game has ups and downs, but in essence it’s the greatest thing ever if you work at it and a nightmare (or lesson) to button-mashers. Thus, since it also teaches, I'm classifying it as the best in the series.