Gamespot you have rated this game totally wrong, it's D&D and should be compared as such. For fans it's a 9+ at leas
User Rating: 9 | Dungeons & Dragons Tactics PSP
I don't normally write reviews due to a busy work life, but I always read them before I buy a game (which is often). I have been a D&D fan since the Amiga 500 Pools of Radiance and then the subsequent 20 games that were released by SSI. Up to all of the NWN and the flop of "again" Pools of Radiance. I have been waiting for D&D Tactics to come out, actually dying for it to come out. I have the fortune of living in Australia, so we get our games a couple of days after the US, so I can gauge Gamespot / User reviews before I purchase the game. When I saw a 5.0 from Gamespot, it actually made me more intrigued to purchase the game as all of the user reviews were 8.0 or above. I bought the game about a month ago, but my lovely girlfriend threw my old (and much loved) PSP against the wall and destroyed it. So I have waited until the slim to purchase another one. Anyway, I have been playing D&D Tactics for a week now and I cannot put it down. For a D&D fan it's awesome, there are a couple of quirks to movement, but hey life is quirky and it only adds to the character of the game. To be honest, the game should be rated on it's genre "PSP-RPG", if that was done by Gamespot, they wouldn't be able to give it any less than an 8.0 (being conservative). My score 9.0, Atari, WSC, Kuju bring out the next one. D&D fans can't wait. 
