It's not that something's seriously wrong with this game, but rather that very few things are right.

User Rating: 4 | Enemy Territory: Quake Wars PC
Positive:
-decent graphics (but nothing exceptional especially if you take a closer look at details)
-the game itself runs smooth and with no major problems

Negative:
-bunny-hopping
-weapons: very few and lousy. Maybe one good thing is the sniper but is almost useless considering the speed of enemy movement
-movement pace: android athletes on steroids laced with crank
-sound: hard to find more uninspiring battle sounds
-dying and respawning: too easy and too quick respectively while battles are brarely or never fierce

Other (mildly negative):
-maps at first look interesting but eventually they all have the same feel to it

Gameplay: 3/10 singleplayer (against computer); 5/10 online MP. Bots have super aim while you can hardly hit anything. Vehicles are pretty much useless. Simple and clear objectives is a plus in otherwise totally uninspired gameplay.

Graphics: 7/10 -- maybe it's simply a crappy engine that doesn't render enough details. Sadly, this is the best part of this game.

Sound: 3/10 -- horrible weapons' and battle sounds.

Value: 3/10. $50 is lots of money for a repetitive and uninspiring game. You'll be better off with CS/BF2/BF2142 until the price of this game comes down to about $20. In my past review I rated BF2142 very low mostly on the account of singleplayer mismanagement, yet I did enjoy BF2142 online play for quite some time. Yet, this game fails even to provoke that urge to play it online, to meet with your friends and enjoy senseless running and gunning.

Overall: 4/10 -- overall, this is a game in which nothing went seriously wrong but also almost nothing is right. The success of this game will completely depend on the MP support and availability of MP servers (which for right now seems ok) -- an MP player is focused on surviving and scoring in an unknown social environment so other factors may not count as much as in my brief review. The real danger is once the player gets familiar with the maps and tricks, the game itself may become increasingly boring ... quickly.