GameSpot was harsh on this game
Story: 8/10 I found the story to be entertaining and fun, You start out as a prince, the brother of a tyrant. Then you over throw him and take his place as king. There weren't that many decisions until you become King but that's no reason to think less of this game.
Gameplay: 7/10 Just like in Fable 2 B for Magic X for Melee and Y for Long Range. The Combat system however is broken it's easy to get knocked down, and repeatedly pressing the same button all the time is what I found vexing. Either way everything is fine.
Sound: 9/10 Great Musical Score. It's not Epic but it's definetly close to being Epic.
Presentation: 9/10 There are a lot of things to do in the world of Albion from buying houses, shops, getting married, having kids, working, the many side quests, the game is Non-linear so you'll probably play it for a long time
The Verdict: 8.5/10 I don't understand why Gamespot gave this game such a average score I think it was better than Fable 2, anyway that's just my opinion.