A train wreck, and not in a good way.
Perhaps we've suddenly been spoilt by the sheer genius and full-on fun of artful masterpieces such as Bioshock and COD4. But I aint apologising for that. A great shooter is just that. Quake 2, I will always enjoy. Quake 3, I will never mention in polite company.
The Darkness showed that shooters can be superficial and dumb but still great slick one-dimensional fun.
The ironically titled FEAR can't even manage dumb properly.