I want to like it but I just can't.
'At least make it believable' is a phrase we're more than used to from films, tv series etc. and it applies perfectly to this game. It's flashy, it's good looking but it just doesn't seem right. The physics, the gameplay, the movement of the ball on the field, frankly everything except the menus and other otherwise unimportant things. I'm sorry but it does seem to me that the developers of this game have never gone out and played a 'good clean fun' game of football with their friends. In a nutshell, I think it's more arcade than simulation.