The reviews won
- shooting physics seem a bit unrealistic. You dont get the filling thta the ball will get where you intend it to go (based on the player's body position).
- sound effects of crossbar are ridiculous and the dynamics of the ball hitting on the up right are not realistic.
- a lot of passes go to the wrong player in a totally wrong direction with what you wanted or the player was facing.
- 99% of the goals are either 1vs 1 or headers. Most of the goals are scored by attackers. Generally we dont see real football situations where midfield players get fast up the field and score many goals.
-all teams feel and play the same. I am a barca fan and I dont see the difference in Barca's game that I see in real football.
- AI in general is very bad. Players very static fail to make thew correct move or passes.
-Virtual pro plays nicely except from the fact that the AI is horrible.
- It doesnt give you the feeling of real football. I played for so many hours and my hands were like I havent played at all. It doesnt make you sweat when the opposition attacks as PES does.
All in all I think fifa fails to give you the real atmosphere and feel of a real football game.