Played the beta and enjoyed almost every second of it.
Several reviewers have said that the graphics are comparable to games from the 90's, but quite frankly those guys are full of crap. It's an MMO so you can't expect the graphics to be like Oblivion's graphics. An MMO with cutting edge graphics would create lag thus screwing up every aspect of the game. But I personally think the graphics are very good. The music can get kind of boring after a while, though. Also the small text can burn your eyes. Also other reviewers have said that the controls basically blow, but I would also have to disagree with that statement. There isn't individual buttons to attack or block or anything like that. But I find this better since there is so many ways to attack your opponent it would be troublesome and kind of confusing with just one button to attack.
There is loads of things to do besides fighting. There are crafting skills, such as fishing, smithing, bonecraft, etc. Also tons of quests and missions. Also a lot of armor and weapons to choose from. There are many jobs to choose from for all those picky people out there. The map is huge with many different monsters and such to engage in combat with.
Another thing that reviewers have mixed feelings about is the combat system. It's not like a hack 'n' slash where you go and keep hitting the attack button until they die. It's the basic, you attack then they attack sort of thing. However, this changes depending on your speed and your opponents speed. Most of you people out there think this system sucks and I used to be one of them. But since most of the higher level monsters out there cannot be soloed you will have to party up with a group of friends (or strangers), thus making it better for you. If they just went all out, they'd blow you away very fast. This way you actually have a chance out there in the wilderness.
Also another thing I failed to mention is that this game for all its content and features, you will have to pay a hefty monthly fine for this game. Although I know a lot of you gamers think $12.95 a month isn't much, it could be for your fellow gamers.
All and all I find this game to be highly enjoyable and addicting. Even if your not a fan I strongly suggest at least giving this game a chance.