The best wrestling game ever made! Just give it a chance.
For example, the creation options take time to understand, but once you have a hand for it, creating an entire roster or ring apron can be done in a short duration of time. Secondly, you can adjust the created wrestlers CPU, allowing a computer controlled wrestler to behave as the real life character would. But again, it takes time to comprehend how this feature is best utilized.
The matches are a blast; I highly suggest experimenting with the battle royal options, especially the endless option. Moreover, the sheer volume of selectable moves is fantastic, so when you're participating in a match with eight wrestlers everyone will have a different move set, and no wrestler is limited to what moves can be assigned.
I will probably play this game forever because it is so much fun. The ability to update every aspect of your roster will keep it fresh. Yes the graphics are to be desired, but again, for the hardcore wrestling purist like me, the game is enjoyable because you can have a phenomenal match regardless of victory or defeat.