It's free, It's addictive...what more could you want.
The graphics are on par with games that came out 1-2 years ago but they're nothing spectacular. They don't displease the eyes so i really can't complain however it could be better thus the 9 for graphics.
Sounds are great and while i personally muted the background music in lue of hearing my own mp3's in the background i wasn't in any way dissatisfied with the overall experience.
Gameplay is similar to every other RPG out there specifically any mmorpg's like UO or online servers for NWN. My main complaint with gameplay is the horrible lag you get, they added new servers but the lag is still there...i suppose for a free game i shouldnt complain too much.
Value is amazing i mean seriously this is a free game and its far better than runescape or adventure quest or any of the other comperable games out there.
If you like RPGs or MMORPG's then download the 400 or so meg file and play for a few hours if you're not addicted then...hey it was free who cares right? but if you're anything like me then you'll be stuck playing 4+ hours a day ;)