Thread Reviews When Posting Replies

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for ValentineRain
ValentineRain

121

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#1 ValentineRain
Member since 2008 • 121 Posts

I think Gamespot should have a topic review feature as you post.
When you push the little button to reply to a thread, whether here or in Union forums, there ought to be a copy of the last page or so of the thread under the text editor for you to review as you respond.

That probably made no sense and I can't think of how to word it, so here is an example.

Among other things, this would be very useful for quoting other users. If you want to know what was said specifically, you would no longer need to either copy your entire post, hit 'back', review it and create the reply again, or make a new tab and navigate back to the thread to re-read it.
This is a pretty basic feature most forums have, but then again most of my experience with this feature has come from PHPbb based forums. I'm not sure whether it is able to be implemented here, because I'm not familiar with the technology involved.

But hey, that's not my job! I'm just supposed to come up with the neat ideas. :D
Anyway, it's pretty annoying having to find my way back to the thread in order to adress key points in a conversation, or to get exact wording on quotations.

What do you guys think?
Thanks in advance, also I like muffins a lot.

[EDIT] Fixed the link. :D

Avatar image for GabuEx
GabuEx

36552

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 27

User Lists: 0

#2 GabuEx
Member since 2006 • 36552 Posts

I'd find something like this useful. I could use quick reply, but the WYSIWYG editor never shows up in it, and the moment that I hit preview, the topic is gone. The only way to get something along those lines at the moment is to open a new tab and navigate back to the thread, which is inconvenient.

Avatar image for double_decker
double_decker

146090

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#3 double_decker
Member since 2006 • 146090 Posts
I don't feel this is needed since if you click "Quote" instead of "Reply" what you are responding to is automatically added already. Then if you don't want to directly quote that person after you are done replying to their post you can delete it from the portion of your message. The Quote box at the bottom of a reply I've never liked and is one of the reasons I only use GameSpot and never go to other forums for posting like IGN etc. If they started doing that here I'd probably stop using the forums and the site entirely.
Avatar image for ValentineRain
ValentineRain

121

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#4 ValentineRain
Member since 2008 • 121 Posts

I don't feel this is needed since if you click "Quote" instead of "Reply" what you are responding to is automatically added already. Then if you don't want to directly quote that person after you are done replying to their post you can delete it from the portion of your message. The Quote box at the bottom of a reply I've never liked and is one of the reasons I only use GameSpot and never go to other forums for posting like IGN etc. If they started doing that here I'd probably stop using the forums and the site entirely.double_decker

Ah, but that doesn't work for multiple-tier quotes, like if you want to respond to more than one person or respond to just one on a point by point basis.
If you don't mind, what about this 'quote box' that I assume is synonymous to what I'm suggesting would break the experience for you? I don't want anything introduced that would chase people off, perhaps it could be modified to be less annoying?

Avatar image for double_decker
double_decker

146090

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#5 double_decker
Member since 2006 • 146090 Posts

Ah, but that doesn't work for multiple-tier quotes, like if you want to respond to more than one person or respond to just one on a point by point basis.
If you don't mind, what about this 'quote box' that I assume is synonymous to what I'm suggesting would break the experience for you? I don't want anything introduced that would chase people off, perhaps it could be modified to be less annoying?

ValentineRain
By quote box I mean where you can go through and click on multiple users quotes and it automatically adds them to a reply box at the bottom of the page instead of directly below the post. Here if you use the "Quick Quote" feature it shows it directly below the post you are replying to. Then you can respond to that post. Scroll down further, and click on "Quick Quote" again to another post you want to reply to and it automatically transfers the previous quote and response to the next reply instead of just adding them to the bottom. I find it much more efficient here than on other forums that use different formats which I think you are describing. If I am mistaken to what you are suggesting then I apologize but from looking at the link in your original post it looks like you are suggesting the same type of thing here.
Avatar image for ValentineRain
ValentineRain

121

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#6 ValentineRain
Member since 2008 • 121 Posts

Oh, neat! Lookit that!

I never even knew that feature existed.
Admittedly, it makes things pretty easy, but I like my way. :D

Thanks for teaching me that, by the way.

Avatar image for double_decker
double_decker

146090

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#7 double_decker
Member since 2006 • 146090 Posts

Thanks for teaching me that, by the way.

ValentineRain
You're welcome, once you get used to it I think you will find it much easier like I did. I can post the other way, it's just more of a hassle, it's easier than scrolling down to the bottom to edit quotes and then going back to where you left off to continue on, this way you can just go through the whole page and submit after you have quoted everything you want to. Although GS automatically cuts quotes now on the wide format so all you can have is 3 so a lot of users have gone to simply using quick reply and then using the "@username - what you want to say" method, but on the old format you can quote as many times in a post as you desire.