I havent played all, but wind wakers really mad cos of the controls and how link is really easy to move around.
However I put LOZ:TP above because Wind waker is too damn sparse with people and its hardly populated. 0v3rcl0ck3d
Lol, they're both sparsly populated but atleast WW has an exscuse, i.e. SEA. Also, i think you'll find their were more people in WW than TP. Besides the characters in WW had a lot more soul and heart than the ones in TP. I cant even remember half the names in TP and i completed it last week for god sake. They actually left that small an impression on me that i cant remember any of the characters bar 8. I can still remember most of the characters in WW and i completed that about 3 years ago.
Twilight Princess trumps Wind Waker in just about every aspect.
Shinobishyguy
I agree gameplay wise TP>>WW..although I gotta admit in terms of story and music........WW trumps TP. Story!?!??!??!@?!?!? umm CHEEZY ALERT!!! Um wind waker is tooo kiddy, GANONDORF IS EXICUTED IN TP in wind waker he goes HAHA and the enmies are ttoo easy in windwaker the graphics the music TP PWNS WINDWAKER!!!
[QUOTE="0v3rcl0ck3d"]I havent played all, but wind wakers really mad cos of the controls and how link is really easy to move around.
However I put LOZ:TP above because Wind waker is too damn sparse with people and its hardly populated. colonel_beeb
Lol, they're both sparsly populated but atleast WW has an exscuse, i.e. SEA. Also, i think you'll find their were more people in WW than TP. Besides the characters in WW had a lot more soul and heart than the ones in TP. I cant even remember half the names in TP and i completed it last week for god sake. They actually left that small an impression on me that i cant remember any of the characters bar 8. I can still remember most of the characters in WW and i completed that about 3 years ago.[/QUOTE Have you been to castle town latley? Corection compleated.
Twilight Princess trumps Wind Waker in just about every aspect.
gigabrowser12
I agree gameplay wise TP>>WW..although I gotta admit in terms of story and music........WW trumps TP. Story!?!??!??!@?!?!? umm CHEEZY ALERT!!! Um wind waker is tooo kiddy, GANONDORF IS EXICUTED IN TP in wind waker he goes HAHA and the enmies are ttoo easy in windwaker the graphics the music TP PWNS WINDWAKER!!! actually.....the story in WW had some pretty dark overtones..such as the epic tail as how a once great kingdom of hyrule was destroyed by the will of the gods and such. But both WW and TP are awesome games, no doubt in my mind about that. however..the sailing in WW was so annoying!
Twilight Princess trumps Wind Waker in just about every aspect.
gigabrowser12
I agree gameplay wise TP>>WW..although I gotta admit in terms of story and music........WW trumps TP. Story!?!??!??!@?!?!? umm CHEEZY ALERT!!! Um wind waker is tooo kiddy, GANONDORF IS EXICUTED IN TP in wind waker he goes HAHA and the enmies are ttoo easy in windwaker the graphics the music TP PWNS WINDWAKER!!!
Dude, um, Wind Waker has probably the second darkest stories, there's extinction, death on a biblical scale, and clear examples of people only clinging to life. TP in comparison sugarcoats it's violence.
Twilight Princess trumps Wind Waker in just about every aspect.
Shirley_Temple
I agree gameplay wise TP>>WW..although I gotta admit in terms of story and music........WW trumps TP. Story!?!??!??!@?!?!? umm CHEEZY ALERT!!! Um wind waker is tooo kiddy, GANONDORF IS EXICUTED IN TP in wind waker he goes HAHA and the enmies are ttoo easy in windwaker the graphics the music TP PWNS WINDWAKER!!!
Dude, um, Wind Waker has probably the second darkest stories, there's extinction, death on a biblical scale, and clear examples of people only clinging to life. TP in comparison sugarcoats it's violence.
I agree. if WW had the same graphics style as TP did then it would have seemed much darker than TP did, and vice versa
TP: Too many dungeons, too much running between towns, too much forced questing....
etc. Shinobi, its pretty clear I'm not alone. Sailing is nothing compared to TP's shortcomings.
o rly? I've seen people state that the sailing killed the experience for them during the end. Don't even try to defend it.
I'm not defending Sailing. You don't even read what I write anymore. I said sailing isn't as bad as TP's replacement's for those sections. Sailing sucked. Sailing sucked hardcore, but it didn't suck as bad as turning into a wolf for the umpteenth time with no way to change back until you've kill an arbitrary number of insects.
TP: Too many dungeons, too much running between towns, too much forced questing....
etc. Shinobi, its pretty clear I'm not alone. Sailing is nothing compared to TP's shortcomings.
o rly? I've seen people state that the sailing killed the experience for them during the end. Don't even try to defend it.
I'm not defending Sailing. You don't even read what I write anymore. I said sailing isn't as bad as TP's replacement's for those sections. Sailing sucked. Sailing sucked hardcore, but it didn't suck as bad as turning into a wolf for the umpteenth time with no way to change back until you've kill an arbitrary number of insects.
http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=25444117&page=1 hmm..scroll through this thread of mine and see what people have to say about this whole bug hunting verses triforce shard debate.
I'm gonna have to go with Twilight Princess on this one. Windwaker was so incredibly childish and cartoony it was insane! But no, it's not just that I like darker games in general (don't deny it... TP was far darker). Both had equal music honestly. Twilight Princess had great tunes! And I don't see where people come up with 'it had no soul'... guys their was so much story to that game it was crazy! I remembered all of the important characters after my first run-through. True it was harder, but that's because Twilight Princess (as any Zelda game will have to that's big and realistic looking), was doing it's best not to be an Ocarina of Time clone. It wasn't. A couple things felt familiar, but not enough to complain about it. C'mon, if Windwaker had realistic graphics, you'd recognize just as many similarities to Ocarina of Time... Don't be hatin' on the new game! TP was great, but it and WW were both too easy. We need more challenge. Like.. MM challenge, more originality with puzzles, and the length of OoT and TP. That's the ideal Zelda game. Oh yeah, and keep the mature Link.
Twilight Princess trumps Wind Waker in just about every aspect.
gigabrowser12
I agree gameplay wise TP>>WW..although I gotta admit in terms of story and music........WW trumps TP. Story!?!??!??!@?!?!? umm CHEEZY ALERT!!! Um wind waker is tooo kiddy, GANONDORF IS EXICUTED IN TP in wind waker he goes HAHA and the enmies are ttoo easy in windwaker the graphics the music TP PWNS WINDWAKER!!!
Did you really finish WW. In TP Link stabs ganadorf through the abdomen. Ganon then does the biggest burp i've ever seen anyone do. In WW Link stabs Ganondorf through the SMEGGING HEAD. Also, TP had easier enemies, no question about it. In fact Nintendo purposefully made it easier. I didnt die once in it. WW on the other hand i died a handful of times in a few dungeon fights.
Twilight Princess trumps Wind Waker in just about every aspect.
colonel_beeb
I agree gameplay wise TP>>WW..although I gotta admit in terms of story and music........WW trumps TP. Story!?!??!??!@?!?!? umm CHEEZY ALERT!!! Um wind waker is tooo kiddy, GANONDORF IS EXICUTED IN TP in wind waker he goes HAHA and the enmies are ttoo easy in windwaker the graphics the music TP PWNS WINDWAKER!!!
Did you really finish WW. In TP Link stabs ganadorf through the abdomen. Ganon then does the biggest burp i've ever seen anyone do. In WW Link stabs Ganondorf through the SMEGGING HEAD. Also, TP had easier enemies, no question about it. In fact Nintendo purposefully made it easier. I didnt die once in it. WW on the other hand i died a handful of times in a few dungeon fights.
yuo actually died in the WW........:lol: The only time I died was during the puppet ganon fight. meanwhile I remember dieing a couple of times in TP during the wolf sections*early on that is* and that Ball&chain minniboss in the snow peak temple.
One of the reasons the CUBE is my favorite system of all time is the fact that you can get practically EVERY Zelda game for it, provided you have the right Collection packages and the GBA Player.
That said, the best Legend of Zelda game for the NGC is not on your list, and you offered no "other" option, so I'll formally cast my vote for "OCARINA OF TIME MASTER QUEST".
Wind Waker is one of the "lesser Zelda's" I've ever played. The unrewarding sailing, small dungeon and secrets lists, and fetch questing made it a much, much weaker game than any of its contemporaries. I'd vote for either the Bonus Disc that contained Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask or Twilight Princess.
Log in to comment