Paper Mario or Mario Sunshine

Which game is better Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door or Super Mario Sunshine?

I couldn't choose from it!

Paper Mario no question.

SMS is good but PM: TTYD is a marvelous game.

Last I checked they were both Player's Choice titles?

I'd just grab them both, both fantastic games in their own way.

(aside from Sunshine's horrific difficulty if you're a completionist) 

They both are different in different ways. Sunshine is your typical Mario game. Yes, some of the stuff is difficult to do, but not impossible. The graphics is pretty amazing compared to the N64.

Paper Mario is unqiue and interesting to play. This has lengthy storyline, (what RPG game doesn't?), sometimes some of the battles can get repeative and annoying, but cool. I've only experienced two or maybe three time, having difficulty beating an enemy.  

   If you really like Mario series, I suggest you to rent both of them. Just play both of them and then decide for yourself which you like better cuz then you can say, "I've played both and I like ----- better, because...so and so."

Paper Mario is better IMO. But if you can get both, get both.mac906

Yeah, get both. But I think that Paper Mario will have more appeal over the years and will become a more sought-after game. 

Paper mario:   completed the game (100%) in 61:33  hours 

sunshine : (23:00 hours i think ) with 119 blue coins.

i'd say get paper mario 

Paper Mario: TTYD is my favorite game for GameCube. Obviously, with that said, Paper Mario gets my vote.

I love both but get SMS