Depends on the genre and my familiarity with the game style. Also depends on certain other elements that can vary wildly between games. For example, look at XCOM: Enemy Within, one of my top 3 favorite single player games last generation. I didn't play it on Impossible mode, the hardest difficulty, because I found it kind of cheap. Instead, I played on Classic mode, the next step down, which was still brutally hard. There are four modes in that game, BTW, Easy, Normal, Classic, and Impossible.
If it's a game that I intend to replay, such as Pillars of Eternity, then I typically spend my first time on the second hardest difficulty (Hard mode for that game) and then I replay it on the hardest (Path of the Damned for PoE).
If it's a standard AAA game, then I play it on the hardest difficulty mode. Like Wolfenstein: the New Order which I recently played. Had no intention or desire to play that game more than once so I bumped it up as high as it went.
One more note: if there's a special highest difficulty mode that includes permadeath in a single player story oriented game (for example, The Witcher 2) then I avoid that. I despise permadeath in that type of game. I'm fine with permadeath in something like The Binding of Isaac or Spelunky, but not in a 40+ hour story based game that would force me to repeat the same material I'd already cleared.
Log in to comment