Favorite Paper Mario Game? (if you played all 3)

What's your favorite Paper Mario game if you played all three? For me, its definetly between the first and second. The third wasn't too good, in my opinion.

What do you think?

Thousand Year Door, not a doubt in my mind. Most endearing characters yet; and the game had so many themes and so much to do! The third only developed a few select characters and relied on gimmicks like 'flipping'. The first was great; amazing and close to the second but lacked support characters as like-able as TYD.

First one was the best.

Mine is super mario rpg on the super nes. And my 2nd fave is on the gc.

Easily TTYD. It expanded on the awsomeness of the origonal. The third was okay. It could have been better.

definetly the first, the second was okay but it never hooked me like the first, and the third was good but its hardly even paper mario besides the actual character sprites :P

The thousand year door is my favorite.

The first one is still my favorite.

The first one

I like Thousand Year Door, because it had so much awesome stuff, like sidequests and a secret character. I played the first, but haven't finished it, so I'm not a fair judge. The third game wasn't really a Paper Mario game, it was more of a normal 2-D Mario game with a twist, but I liked that as well, but it can't compare to the other ones.

I liked the first one more

I played the second one first, so that's when it was first new and fresh to me... but even with less impressive graphics, I found the original more enjoyable. Personally, I thought Super Paper Mario (i.e. #3) to be completely awful... I couldn't even finish it. I was like a dozen hours in and it just never became fun for me, even if some of the perspective shifts were kinda cool. I thought a lot of the art design in #3 was also really lazy... the other games were more visually interesting and colorful, which is ridiculous to me.

If I had to pick one, it would be The Thousand Year Door. but honestly, i didn't really like any of them.

The first one is and will always be the best in the series. TTYD is also very good, but Super Paper Mario just made me sad... If you're going to make a side-scrolling Mario game, keep Paper Mario out of the title.

The first one easily, I likeds the plot more then the other two and did'nt like how they they changed the partner system for TTYD.

I liked the first but the second was slightly more enjoyable.

Super Paper Mario wasn't a bad game if you saw it as a platformer and not an RPG.

The first onehad much better boss music though...

The first one is the best one.

I like the first and third one better. I never really played the second one.

I thought all 3 Paper mario games were great. While I do like the RPG format of the first two better, I still really enjoyed Super Paper Mario's gameplay. And if Paper mario is known for one thing, it is that it has awesome boss battle themes!

I never really understood how people could think "Super paper mario is not a real Paper mario!" For one, it is a Mario game that is all paper-like. Two, SPM retained some of the RPG aspects of the past two Paper m,ario games, such as the badge system, and switching between characters (as well as pixels), and the level up system is the same as well, I believe. and lastly, SPM, like the past two games, was seperated into chapters.

SPM felt like a paper mario game to me. I don't care if you don't like the game, but still, that doesn't make it any less of a Paper Mario game.

I'd say Paper Mario 1>Super Paper Mario>>>>The Thousand Year Door. I didn't really like Thousand Year Door, not sure why, but Paper Mario 1 was probably my favorite N64 game and Super Paper Mario was great. =)