Gta 3 vs vice vs san

Yeah I'll probably only get one, so in your opinion which is best (Ill buy the one with most votes)?

**** slaps you* Getting one GTA is like only getting one FF. play them all or die =)

Ha ha I guess.. I'm sure I'll get a second slapping for this though, but aren't they all kinda the same..? I've never played one but it seems to me they're just sandbox games with a little story thrown in, so is there a point buying two sandboxes.. Or is my perception completely false?

GTA3 for its day was mind blowing - however that was years ago now, and in the two sequals that followed, it was improved upon massivly. I loved GTA3, however after GTA:SA i couldn't go back to it. If you intend to get all 3 (which i would strongly recomend) go for this one first - imo it has the coolest city of pretty much any sandbox game to date and some really memorable moments. Chatterbox is also the best radio station EVER (including real life). Vice city is really fun and probably has the strongest story (think scarface parody) and most vibrant art direction (again, tacky 80's ftw!) and Vice city has some really nice areas too. Also, Vice City has some really fun property based jobs, which were for some reason scaled back in SA

If you're only gonna get one though, it has to be SA imo. In terms of scale it dwarfes the other two (3 cities, a mountain, redneck forests AND a desert), it has Samuel Jackson in it, planes take on a whole new level, there are multyplayer elements, character customisation takes on a whole new level (u can be fat, skinny, buff, whatever), you can swim and has gang turf wars...Some people felt there was too much to do in this game and that it thus lost focus however these people are wrong imo.

But yeah, as has been said - get all three - they are gaming histroy, and amongst the best games of the last generation, if not ever, and i'm sure u can get them really cheap in decent condition

GTA3 for its day was mind blowing - however that was years ago now, and in the two sequals that followed, it was improved upon massivly. I loved GTA3, however after GTA:SA i couldn't go back to it. If you intend to get all 3 (which i would strongly recomend) go for this one first - imo it has the coolest city of pretty much any sandbox game to date and some really memorable moments. Chatterbox is also the best radio station EVER (including real life). Vice city is really fun and probably has the strongest story (think scarface parody) and most vibrant art direction (again, tacky 80's ftw!) and Vice city has some really nice areas too. Also, Vice City has some really fun property based jobs, which were for some reason scaled back in SA

If you're only gonna get one though, it has to be SA imo. In terms of scale it dwarfes the other two (3 cities, a mountain, redneck forests AND a desert), it has Samuel Jackson in it, planes take on a whole new level, there are multyplayer elements, character customisation takes on a whole new level (u can be fat, skinny, buff, whatever), you can swim and has gang turf wars...Some people felt there was too much to do in this game and that it thus lost focus however these people are wrong imo.

But yeah, as has been said - get all three - they are gaming histroy, and amongst the best games of the last generation, if not ever, and i'm sure u can get them really cheap in decent condition

real_nimrod

From those three, Vice City is the best.

Get either III or VC.

San Andreas was by far the worst of the 3.

If I had to choose 1, I thin GTA III is the best.

*glares at your avvy, but...*I never played GTA3, and Vice City's good, but San Andreas is a LOT better IMO, so I'd go with that.

I would strongly recommend GTA: SA because it is such a larger game and the characters are really well done! Who else cared about what happened to our friend Carl Johnson?

san andreas best gta ever then it would be vice city than game was amazing then gta 3 which started the new layout for gta which was also amazing but not as good as the other two but i didnt enjoy gta iv

Vice City and San andreas are both pretty much equal in my opinion.

GTA3 isnt as good, but still great

What an obscure debate, this is too hard. But, San Andreas is the obvious choice because of it's huge environment and polish graphics. *Clicks "Vote San Andreas."* *Views Results* Yep, San Andreas.

i prefer vice city over the rest.

CJs sayings are funny enought to buy the game alone

san andras all the way

SA had a ridiculous amount of silly mini games that held up the story and made it frustrating to play at times, I think Vice City was a maasive improvement on GTA III and a lot nicer to play than SA, espcecially if you've not played a GTA game before.