In a nutshell, what is good and bad about Red Dead Online at the moment?

Like it says in the title

You don't feel rewarded like in the single player.

Single player had a narrative and interesting cast of characters, including the protagonist. As well as various areas with a interesting story, interesting side missions given by a wide range of people that allows the world to feel vibrant.

Online has little to do besides shoot other players either on the world map or in game modes, attack some bandit campsites and a "story" campaign that doesn't do enough to invest the player in it nor convince that their character is nothing more then someone just flowing with it like a stick down a river.

You can't state "bad" and anything "Red Dead Redemption 2" in the same sentence. It's been heavily claimed here as the greatest game ever made! Even before its release date no-less.