(NES/SNES) Another Difficult Question!

Picking up where my first question left off. The winner was Super Mario Bros. 3, so...

You were playing Super Mario Bros. 3 in nothingness, when all of a sudden, two glowing doors appear before you.

One is silver and has this inscribed on it:

The other door is golden and has this inscribed on it:

Once you went through one of the doors, you could never go back and enter the other. Which one would you choose?

any version other than the NES version is just not the same. NES all the way!

NES version

NES version. I don't like the look of the All-Stars version.

NES version for sure. The other ones are fun and portable, but the NES version tops them.

NES version is the only version as far as I care.

Yep, NES version all the way.

NES. Why? Because Mario turned completely orange when he got fire power, lol.

SNES, it lets you save and fixed a few things. It also features a super fun battle mode for two players.Black_Knight_00

I'm loving the post :P

The NES version. I adore the SNES version, but the NES version has a charm that can never be matched. It's the original, classic, first version, and in my book, you just can't beat that.

I like the game play in the original nes better then the two remakes but I do enjoy the save feature that was added to the later editions. For convence I tend to play the snes version more frequently as I do not have the time to sit through and complete all 8 worlds in one sitting. Through in save states however (like on my DS or PSP) then its the nes version all the way.

Definately the nes version.

Super Mario Bros 3 on the NES was a better looking game than the snes one. I liked All Stars, but it just didn't feel like the same game.

NES.

The SNES tried to beef up the graphics, it just annoyed me. NES version is that beautiful pure form. And I'm fortunate enough to own the original cartridge.

I thought Mario looked a bit too tanned in the SNES/GBA versions.

NES version, why tamper with a good thing. originalis always the way to go.

NES. Why? Because Mario turned completely orange when he got fire power, lol.

kitchenwindow

Yep, SNES.

i'm personally gonna go with the NES version. I donno, it just felt more natural, like the evolution of mario. I couldn't get over the feel of the SNES version

NES. Why? Because Mario turned completely orange when he got fire power, lol.

kitchenwindow

I've enjoyed playing through all three versions of the game. The NES version is the original, so that increases its nostalgic value. The SNES version updated the graphics, as well as introduced a user-friendly save feature. Finally, the GBA version is portable, allowing gameplay outside the home.

I can understand why others bash the remakes due to the updated graphics, minor tweaks in difficulty, and, in the GBA's case, the smaller screen size, but those have never bothered me.

Owning both, I prefer the All-Stars version. The SMB3 on AS is the one I've actully beaten.

That said, I still prefer SMB to SMB 3 on NES.