So is GTA4 really a 10?

hmm good question...

i didnt buy it (yet) but i played it and it is alot of fun...

i dont know how to answer ur question, but imo it is a 10

just to let u know, gamespot actually gave gta4 a 9.5, but changed it as everyone else gave it a 10...

I've heard about how they created a city that really feels "alive" in the way people react and things like that, basically that they took environment creation in games to the next level, so it's apparently a big step forward in gaming as a whole. Anyway, I sure hope it's a leap forward, since you can get all 3 previous games (GTA3, Vice City, and San Andreas) as a package for $30 on Steam now. :P

hmm good question...

i didnt buy it (yet) but i played it and it is alot of fun...

i dont know how to answer ur question, but imo it is a 10

just to let u know, gamespot actually gave gta4 a 9.5, but changed it as everyone else gave it a 10...

dark-ottsel

And you know that happend and that is the reason how?

Depends on what you think deserves a 10.

I would give it a 10, just because it raises the bar for other games to come. It's about time a title's makers payed attention to the fine details again. It's been a long while since a game like this has been made. To long.

It's... kinda like playing Heat and Scarface all rolled into one phatty, held together with homemade honey, twisted on a virgins thighs and lite with burning roses.

It smokes nice and smooth. So "Stay Alpha!"

Btw... This isn't coming from a GTA fanboy either. This is the first GTA I'v ever played.

hmm good question...

i didnt buy it (yet) but i played it and it is alot of fun...

i dont know how to answer ur question, but imo it is a 10

just to let u know, gamespot actually gave gta4 a 9.5, but changed it as everyone else gave it a 10...

dark-ottsel

proof plz

[QUOTE="dark-ottsel"]

hmm good question...

i didnt buy it (yet) but i played it and it is alot of fun...

i dont know how to answer ur question, but imo it is a 10

just to let u know, gamespot actually gave gta4 a 9.5, but changed it as everyone else gave it a 10...

massiv-damage

proof plz

well i saw tht too...but not sure where i can get a picture of it. i remmber seeing the pic on another forum one of my friends showed me.

Brucey's one-liners alone make that game worthy of a 10.hazbazz

What I'll say is this:

For publications that regularly give out 10's to the top games each year, YES, GTA 4 is a 10.

For publications that do NOT regularly give out 10's to the top games each year, and instead usually dish out scores in the mid to high 9's for such games like IGN and Gamespot, NO, GTA 4 does not deserve a 10.

Its an incredible game for its time. But so were GTA 3, Halo Combat Evolved, and Metroid Prime, among others. I don't remember them getting 10's though, from places that don't normally dish them out.