What should I play next?

I just finished Tomb Raider:Legend on gametap. As I loved it, my first instinct was to rush out and buy Anniversary (users in the UK can't subscribe to gametap yet). Then I looked at my shelf of shame (games I've bought but haven't played) These include, in no particular order:

Beyond Good and Evil

Jade Empire: Special Edition

Company of Heroes

Warhammer 40000: Dawn of war (came free with CoH)

Oblivion (I got 40 hours into this last year without touching the storyline - I'd like to go back and play through the story)

ICO (PS2)

Psi Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy (PS2)

Killer7 (PS2)

Dreamfall: The Longest Journey

I really ought to deal with at least one of these before I buy another game. Indecision is killing me. Can anyone here help?

edit: forgot one, all games are PC version unless otherwise stated.

I think you should finish up Oblivion!! try out your Company of Heroes also!!:P

I'd say that it's a toss-up between Beyond Good and Evil, Killer7 and Dreamfall.

If you've played The Longest Journey, then you'd probably want to play Dreamfall now....

Beyond Good and Evil would probably be one of the shorter of the bunch and is a good experience. Oblivion would just take a long time if you want to "bang one out" to satisfy your incomplete sensation.

Company of Heroes is a good one too. I only vaguely remember Psi-Ops, but I remember enjoying it a lot when I played it.

OH MY GOD! PLAY DREAMFALL.

Go play Beyond Good and Evil right about now!Black_Knight_00

Thanks guys. I'm still in the mood for more 3rd person action/adventuring after Tomb Raider, so I'm playing Beyond Good and Evil. [...]drbob

Yay! I win!!