Heath Miller : Offensive Rookie of the year ?

Not even close.  It'll be Cadillac.VanHalun040604

Only if he can pick up his game after the injury.  He hasn't done that yet.  Right now I'd say Ronnie Brown.

I'd come down to the two former teammates

Cadillac Williams vs Ronnie Brown.

If Cadillac's numbers continue to grow after the injury he get's my vote.

If he doesn't rebound from the injury, I would say Ronnie Brown.

I'd come down to the two former teammates

Cadillac Williams vs Ronnie Brown.

If Cadillac's numbers continue to grow after the injury he get's my vote.

If he doesn't rebound from the injury, I would say Ronnie Brown.

Toucanbird

Yes, it's Cadillac's trophy to lose.NYJCMart28

Hes losing it, 13,20, and 29 yrds for his last 3 games does not a rookie of the year make

[QUOTE="NYJCMart28"]Yes, it's Cadillac's trophy to lose.yamabushi98

Hes losing it, 13,20, and 29 yrds for his last 3 games does not a rookie of the year make

Yeah, I agree with you there. Especially for that kind of perfomance vs SAN FRANCISCO! Honestly, it is looking more and more like Ronnie Brown's trophy. I don't see Heath Miller getting it. I don't think he had a very good game against the Packers. Then again, look who was throwing the ball. :roll:

[QUOTE="yamabushi98"]

[QUOTE="NYJCMart28"]Yes, it's Cadillac's trophy to lose.Toucanbird

Hes losing it, 13,20, and 29 yrds for his last 3 games does not a rookie of the year make

Yeah, I agree with you there. Especially for that kind of perfomance vs SAN FRANCISCO! Honestly, it is looking more and more like Ronnie Brown's trophy. I don't see Heath Miller getting it. I don't think he had a very good game against the Packers. Then again, look who was throwing the ball. :roll:

:lol:  Good ol' Charlie Batch....I was hoping the Packers would upset in that game.  But then Favre got absolutely SMACKED and Polamalu took the fumble to the house.  Great for my fantasy team.  Bad for Brett and the Pack.  Polamalu's probably my favorite safety.  I would have liked to see the upset, though.