Overrated player - Chris Mcalister CB, Ravens Underrated player - Mike Brown S, Bears Overrated Coach - Herman Edwards Chiefs Underrated Coach - Mike Nolan 49ers
Overrated player- Michael Vick...teams are starting to figure him out Underrated player- Nick Barnett...he'll get better at MLB, he's got the speed to get anywhere on the field. Overrated coach- Tony Dungy...if this guy were coaching anywhere else, and didn't have a talent like the Colts do, he would have been fired by now. Underrated coach- Romeo Crenell...well, all I can say is that he did a good job filling in as the Browns coach. The Browns certainly weren't considered to do anything and they were able to get a couple upsets during the year.
Overrated= Mike Vick Underrated= Juilius Jones, he is a stud and never gets talked about like the 'Edgerrin James' or the 'Shaun Alexanders', He did miss a good junk of playing time each of his seasons.
*Overrated Coach= Bill Belichick, he did good with New England, but what about his stint with the Browns?? *Underrated= Nick Saban, I am speaking a bit early, but this dude turned around a dump of a franchise into almost wild card contenders. He also convinced Ricky to come back which paid off.
Overrated player- Michael Vick...teams are starting to figure him out
geaux321
Couldn't have said it better.
Vick sells tickets and makes people watch games. Does that make him overrated? Nah.. he's just fun to watch.
He isn't overrated.  He is rated LOW. The media talks nothing but negative negative negative. "Vick can't throw.. Vick isn't comfortable."  Listen to you guys for instance.  You believe that teams are starting to figure him out. You can't be overrated if everybody has you rated low.
I'm a fan of Vick, but I know he needs to improve.
Overrated player- Michael Vick...teams are starting to figure him out
kctree
Couldn't have said it better.
Vick sells tickets and makes people watch games. Does that make him overrated? Nah.. he's just fun to watch.
He isn't overrated. He is rated LOW. The media talks nothing but negative negative negative. "Vick can't throw.. Vick isn't comfortable." Listen to you guys for instance. You believe that teams are starting to figure him out. You can't be overrated if everybody has you rated low.
I'm a fan of Vick, but I know he needs to improve.
Well I still hear talks of him being a great QB, which he is not, so therefore that makes him overrated.
overrated player: Kerry Collins (why do teams keep picking this guy up? he chokes so bad it makes me sick!)
underrated player: Domanik (sp?) Davis (he has been hurt off and on but he is a killer when he plays. Houston is better off picking up Williams in the draft and beefing up their D because Davis is a very good RB)
overrated coach: Billichek (he's not as good as they say, nor are his Pats)
underrated coach: Mike Nolan (had the Niners in a lot of games even with a horrible offense and decent defense)
Log in to comment