If I like Spirit Tracks, will I like Phantom Hourglass too?

I know a lot of people don't like the DS Zelda games, but so far I am really liking Spirit Tracks. So do you think I would also like Phantom Hourglass?

Umm, I think it WOULD have been better to play Phantom Hourglass before playing Spirit Tracks. (Since it's the sequal.) But yeah, I think you should buy Phantom Hourglass.

spirit tracks is a masterpiece. phantom hourglass is good, but might get tiresome if you spend too much time on the temple of the ocean king or sailing. PH is still a good game, but i'm not sure how you'll react after having contact with a game far superior :PBrunoBRS

The exact opposite

i'm on the same boat. i thought PH was a masterpiece, and ST was good, but cumbersome. i hate that stupid train.

[QUOTE="BrunoBRS"]spirit tracks is a masterpiece. phantom hourglass is good, but might get tiresome if you spend too much time on the temple of the ocean king or sailing. PH is still a good game, but i'm not sure how you'll react after having contact with a game far superior :PCruse34

The exact opposite

i'm on the same boat.

dr_doongy

Yes definitely! I started with PH and then moved onto ST and I'm loving it :)

[QUOTE="Cruse34"]

[QUOTE="BrunoBRS"]spirit tracks is a masterpiece. phantom hourglass is good, but might get tiresome if you spend too much time on the temple of the ocean king or sailing. PH is still a good game, but i'm not sure how you'll react after having contact with a game far superior :PBrunoBRS

The exact opposite

The only thing I liked better about ST was the title song, and the snake whip, But both games are masterpieces because there are of course Zelda games and there both in the top 5 of my favorite DS games. I found PH to have more personallity, and I didn't hate the temple or boat

They are pretty much the same game, as far as design goes, with the differences being in some gameplay devices.

I personally enjoyed Phantom Hourglass, as it takes most of its gameplay elements from Wind Waker. Spirt Tracks is a very, very similar game overall, but I just did not enjoy the dual character control aspect of the gameplay. It just became tedious and boring very quickly.

i'm on the same boat. i thought PH was a masterpiece, and ST was good, but cumbersome. i hate that stupid train.

dr_doongy

They are pretty much the same game, as far as design goes, with the differences being in some gameplay devices.

I personally enjoyed Phantom Hourglass, as it takes most of its gameplay elements from Wind Waker. Spirt Tracks is a very, very similar game overall, but I just did not enjoy the dual character control aspect of the gameplay. It just became tedious and boring very quickly.

evilross

the train got boring fast too, with a horrible "stargate" warp system

I felt ST was much more refined and an all around better experience than PH. PH was a major letdown for me, and it remains one of my least favorite zelda games, IMO of course. As far as im concerned ST is the better game, it may not have changed things up drastically but it improved upon and fixed nearly all the faults i felt PH had, better music, better menus and design, and a better setting. So my advice to you is just stick with ST, PH and its ocean of the temple king are one thing you can afford to miss.

[QUOTE="Cruse34"]

[QUOTE="BrunoBRS"]spirit tracks is a masterpiece. phantom hourglass is good, but might get tiresome if you spend too much time on the temple of the ocean king or sailing. PH is still a good game, but i'm not sure how you'll react after having contact with a game far superior :PBrunoBRS

The exact opposite

I agree 100% with Bruno.

I was actually disappointed in Spirit Tracks. And seeing how similar it was to Phantom Hourglass, I have a feeling that if I went back and played PH now, I'd find that I didn't like it nearly as much as I thought I did. Or maybe I should give Spirit Tracks a year, and then play it again to see if I disliked it as much as I thought I did?

I dunno. I'd better sleep on this...

Phantom Hourglass is inferior to Spirit Tracks in almost every way, besides graphics and music. There is far more content in SP, and the central dungeon in PH needs to be repeated every time you beat a dungeon and that almost breaks the game. However, PH is still a good game, just not up to Zelda standards. Overall, though, I enjoyed it.