If zelda a link to the past was remade with 3D gameplay?

Would you buy it? Link to the past is a classic zelda game, and if they remade it with 3D environments it would be awesome. Maybe make the bosses harder with different attack patterns, hide all the heart peices in different locations, and put weapons/tools, that arent found in dungeons, in different locations.

I would buy a Wii just to play it.

And people wonder why there are sooo many remakes instead of actual sequels and new ip's. Exhibit A everybody, take note.nini200

[QUOTE="nini200"]And people wonder why there are sooo many remakes instead of actual sequels and new ip's. Exhibit A everybody, take note.wiifan001

I would buy five copies of it. Day one. Pre-ordered. Collectors Edition.

It would have to be a magnificent remake,and NOT for a portable.

I think the game is great as it is. I would love a 3D game of Zelda 2. I love the game but the style wasn't recieved to well by most. Now this is as long as by 3D you mean like when Ocarina of Time first came out, not the new 3DS release. I don't like that particular gimmick.

It would have to be a magnificent remake,and NOT for a portable.

GreekGameManiac

I'd play it if the gameplay wasn't altered. If it was remade to be like Ocarina of Time or something I wouldn't be interested. But a top down isometric with vamped up graphics... I'd go that.

And people wonder why there are sooo many remakes instead of actual sequels and new ip's. Exhibit A everybody, take note.nini200

Well part of it is fan request. The other part is that it's easier to tweak a game you already made before rather than making a brand new game from scratch. These remakes pay the bills.

I wouldn't mind a 3D remake of it. That would be cool.

I would buy five copies of it. Day one. Pre-ordered. Collectors Edition.

WreckEm711

Nah, leave ALttP alone.... it doesn't need a remake.

Besides.... OoT basically is ALttP in 3D....

I'd rather an entirely new Zelda game be made.wiifan001

i agree with this. as much asi loved ALttP i really think its time for newer zelda games to be made instead of remakes. i would like to see a new zelda game made for the 3ds with the same style as ALttP though...

I will not buy it because I have already played the original.

I'd rather an entirely new Zelda game be made.wiifan001

[QUOTE="wiifan001"]I'd rather an entirely new Zelda game be made.AlmightyDerek

Actually, Zelda gets more remakes than any Nintendo first party title.nini200

[QUOTE="AlmightyDerek"][QUOTE="wiifan001"]I'd rather an entirely new Zelda game be made.nini200

[QUOTE="nini200"][QUOTE="wiifan001"] There are only 2 Zelda remakes.. Super Mario Bros 1, 2, 3, and "the Lost Levels" got a remake, as did mario tennis on the gamecubewiifan001

[QUOTE="wiifan001"][QUOTE="nini200"] Mario 1, 2 and 3 got remakes? When? nini200

All those super mario bros games I mentioned are remakes, not ports. They built them from the ground up constructed of 16 bit with more detail in the characters and the background as 2 prime examples. And the Mario Tennis game got motion controls. Remakes yes, ports no.

[QUOTE="nini200"]

[QUOTE="wiifan001"] the super mario all stars collection.wiifan001

That's not a remake, that's a port. Nothing was updated in any one of those games. Zelda has had updates in the Gamecube version and the 3DS version. All those super mario bros games I mentioned are remakes, not ports. They built them from the ground up constructed of 16 bit with more detail in the characters and the background as 2 prime examples. And the Mario Tennis game got motion controls. Remakes yes, ports no.

[QUOTE="nini200"][QUOTE="AlmightyDerek"] We get new Zelda games pretty often, we rarely ever get Zelda remakes. OoT 3D and I guess the color version of Link's Awakening are the closest things to them. If ALTTP was remade I'd rather have it in the same 2D style just with higher resolution, widescreen graphics. The first Zelda is the game that needs remade the most. If they did do a 3D modern take on it, it would probably feel like a new game.wiifan001

Yeah their are only 2 Zelda remakes. Anything else is a port, or a rom on the virtual console/ Gamecube Collector's edition. A remake is something that is completely redone. Even the color version of Link's Awakening isn't really a clear cut remake as it's really just an enhanced port, but I'll count it anyway. I actually think Kirby gets the most remakes of a Nintendo game.

Yeah their are only 2 Zelda remakes. Anything else is a port, or a rom on the virtual console/ Gamecube Collector's edition. A remake is something that is completely redone. Even the color version of Link's Awakening isn't really a clear cut remake as it's really just an enhanced port, but I'll count it anyway. I actually think Kirby gets the most remakes of a Nintendo game.

AlmightyDerek

A remake of the greatest game ever made? I'd buy it in a heartbeat. If they made 20 more sequels to a link to the past (remake)I'd never buy another game other then Zelda.

It's a great game, but I've never been the "die-hard" fan that some people are. I thoroughly enjoyed it then, on my recent play through I enjoyed it, but remaking it in 3D really doesn't appeal to me. I want a new Zelda adventure.

[QUOTE="wiifan001"][QUOTE="nini200"] Actually, Zelda gets more remakes than any Nintendo first party title.nini200

OoT on the vc is not a remake; that's mere button mapping.

When did A Link to the Past get a remake?

[QUOTE="nini200"][QUOTE="wiifan001"] There are only 2 Zelda remakes.. Super Mario Bros 1, 2, 3, and "the Lost Levels" got a remake, as did mario tennis on the gamecubewiifan001

OoT on the vc is not a remake; that's mere button mapping.

When did A Link to the Past get a remake?

http://nintendo.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_The_Legend_of_Zelda_remakes

Actually I just did some research and Zelda has had more remakes. Link's Awakening DX, Ocarina of Time: Master Quests, Ocarina of Time WiiWare/VC, Ocarina of Time 3D and A Link to the Past.nini200

OoT on the vc is not a remake; that's mere button mapping.

When did A Link to the Past get a remake?

[QUOTE="nini200"][QUOTE="wiifan001"]

OoT on the vc is not a remake; that's mere button mapping.

When did A Link to the Past get a remake?

wiifan001

Read the comments as well. Also, look at the link I posted previously to see where this info is coming from.

[QUOTE="wiifan001"][QUOTE="nini200"] Yes, OoT on VC had slightly enhanced visuals. It is a remakenini200

Read the description as well

[QUOTE="nini200"]

[QUOTE="wiifan001"] Do you have a link? ^ Also, when did A Link to the Past get a remake?wiifan001

Read the description as well

Also this link proves that additional content and higher resolution has been updated to the GC/VC versions:

http://zeldaspeedruns.com/oot/generalknowledge/version-differences

[QUOTE="wiifan001"][QUOTE="nini200"] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fmi9Ra8hxkU

Read the description as well

nini200

Also this link proves that additional content and higher resolution has been updated to the GC/VC versions:

http://zeldaspeedruns.com/oot/generalknowledge/version-differences

I'm not taking youtube comments as legit. I don't see a difference in that 240p only vid, my bad, not seeing it.

Now the other link you provided, that's legit. That can be worked with.

There is no remake to A Link to the Past...unless you want to refer to the GBA version that was redone. If then though, I get to use all the handhelds to prove Mario had the most remakes even further.

Super Mario Advance 1 (which got both Mario Bros and the U.S. super mario bros 2), 2, 3 and 4 all on the gba along with the remakes super mario bros 1 and 2 (Japanese version) got on the gbc in super mario bros deluxe. Follow that up the remakes with mario tennis on the gamecube. Finish it off with the 16 bit remakes of super mario bros 1, 2, 3, and the lost levels...which unlike Ocarina of Time was merely emulated at a higher resolution and button mapped and a couple minor things...got completely remade from scratch.

Mario has the most remakes.

[QUOTE="nini200"]

[QUOTE="wiifan001"] How am I supposed to take anything from that? It's in 240p, and not legit enough for my convincing. I am expecting a source, not some low res youtube vid. ....and that A Link to The Past remake?wiifan001

Also this link proves that additional content and higher resolution has been updated to the GC/VC versions:

http://zeldaspeedruns.com/oot/generalknowledge/version-differences

I'm not taking youtube comments as legit. I don't see a difference in that 240p only vid, my bad, not seeing it.

Now the other link you provided, that's legit. That can be worked with.

There is no remake to A Link to the Past...unless you want to refer to the GBA version that was redone. If then though, I get to use all the handhelds to prove Mario had the most remakes even further.

Super Mario Advance 1 (which got both Mario Bros and the U.S. super mario bros 2), 2, 3 and 4 all on the gba along with the remakes super mario bros 1 and 2 (Japanese version) got on the gbc in super mario bros deluxe. Follow that up the remakes with mario tennis on the gamecube. Finish it off with the 16 bit remakes of super mario bros 1, 2, 3, and the lost levels...which unlike Ocarina of Time was merely emulated at a higher resolution and button mapped and a couple minor things...got completely remade from scratch.

Mario has the most remakes.

I would but I would rather have new Zelda game like say??? Skyward Sword.

I think I would prefer a brand new Zelda game, but it would be amazing to have A Link to the Past remade (same world and story and so on, but completely different graphics and gameplay) on the WiiU with amazing graphics in full 3D. The world of ALTTP is so darn good that it would be amazing to see it in 3D with top tier graphics.

I think I would prefer a brand new Zelda game, but it would be amazing to have A Link to the Past remade (same world and story and so on, but completely different graphics and gameplay) on the WiiU with amazing graphics in full 3D. The world of ALTTP is so darn good that it would be amazing to see it in 3D with top tier graphics.

NaveedLife

i agree, that would be awesome