Nintendo Power, I am disappointed in your score for Super Mario Galaxy.

http://gonintendo.com/?p=29894#comments

Sure, you may be thinking. "A 9.5 is superb!", but after they gave Metriod Prime 3 a perfect 10 and Fire Emblem a 9.5, the score seems rather pitiful now. If there's any Wii game out there that's as close to perfect as can be, Super Mario Galaxy is that game. It should have gotten a 10 from them.

They gave the most recent Fire Emblem a 10?!HelloJon

No, they gave it a 9.5, which was still a rediculously high score for that game.

rayman raving rabbids got a 6.5????

the simpsons game got a 4.0??????

Please people, rather then complaining that a game got 0.5 less then perfect, focus on some of those other scores that are actually LOW for what they should be.

I LOVE rayman raving rabbids 2, i dunno why its getting all these low scores, id give it an 8.5

the simpsons game i rented and would give it a 7.0.

FE probabaly doesnt even deserve an 8.0Cyber-

i thought nintendo power wasnt handled by nintendo anymore. that might have something to do with it

Well... I give it a 9.5 considering its so freakin' easy.Rocky32189

Outside of Lost Levels what Mario platformer has ever been hard?

rayman raving rabbids got a 6.5????

the simpsons game got a 4.0??????

Please people, rather then complaining that a game got 0.5 less then perfect, focus on some of those other scores that are actually LOW for what they should be.

I LOVE rayman raving rabbids 2, i dunno why its getting all these low scores, id give it an 8.5

the simpsons game i rented and would give it a 7.0.

gamer6464

I thought the simpsons game was absolute crap.

[QUOTE="HelloJon"]They gave the most recent Fire Emblem a 10?!Super-Mario-Fan

No, they gave it a 9.5, which was still a rediculously high score for that game.

FE probabaly doesnt even deserve an 8.0Cyber-

[QUOTE="Super-Mario-Fan"]

[QUOTE="HelloJon"]They gave the most recent Fire Emblem a 10?!kingqaz

No, they gave it a 9.5, which was still a rediculously high score for that game.

FE probabaly doesnt even deserve an 8.0Cyber-

what does mispelling a word have to do with ever playing a game? Also even if he hasent played it he can still see that none of the other review sites have given it a very high score, which means it does not derserve that great of a mark. So we have learned two lessons today

1.) grammer does not have anything to do if you played or havent played a game before

2.) Even if you havent played the game before, it doesnt mean its good.

[QUOTE="kingqaz"][QUOTE="Super-Mario-Fan"]

[QUOTE="HelloJon"]They gave the most recent Fire Emblem a 10?!alexh_99

No, they gave it a 9.5, which was still a rediculously high score for that game.

FE probabaly doesnt even deserve an 8.0Cyber-

what does mispelling a word have to do with ever playing a game? Also even if he hasent played it he can still see that none of the other review sites have given it a very high score, which means it does not derserve that great of a mark. So we have learned two lessons today

1.) grammer does not have anything to do if you played or havent played a game before

2.) Even if you havent played the game before, it doesnt mean its good.

[QUOTE="Rocky32189"]Well... I give it a 9.5 considering its so freakin' easy.Gamer46

Outside of Lost Levels what Mario platformer has ever been hard?

Galaxy is definately the easiest of all. But all the 2D games were much much harder especially the NES games.

[QUOTE="kingqaz"][QUOTE="Super-Mario-Fan"]

[QUOTE="HelloJon"]They gave the most recent Fire Emblem a 10?!alexh_99

No, they gave it a 9.5, which was still a rediculously high score for that game.

FE probabaly doesnt even deserve an 8.0Cyber-

what does mispelling a word have to do with ever playing a game? Also even if he hasent played it he can still see that none of the other review sites have given it a very high score, which means it does not derserve that great of a mark. So we have learned two lessons today

1.) grammer does not have anything to do if you played or havent played a game before

2.) Even if you havent played the game before, it doesnt mean its good.

I have played it and when I read what that noob said i did this :lol:

I have played it and when I read what that noob said i did this :lol:

Cyber-

[QUOTE="Cyber-"]

I have played it and when I read what that noob said i did this :lol:

kingqaz

2)How many parts is this game split up to?
3)What is the new laguz species added to this game?
Anyone who played this game would be able to answer these easily.

im not gonna be anyone's lapdog. The fact that you equated my bad grammer to the knowledge of game is just dumb. the series needs advancement and they refuse to do this.

[QUOTE="Gamer46"]

[QUOTE="Rocky32189"]Well... I give it a 9.5 considering its so freakin' easy.Rocky32189

Outside of Lost Levels what Mario platformer has ever been hard?

Galaxy is definately the easiest of all. But all the 2D games were much much harder especially the NES games.

I agree, Galaxy is REDICULOUSLY easy.

Man Fire Emblem is creating a lot of controversy as of late. Well atleast it is getting attention, that's what I always wanted Fire Emblem to get more of.

And whoever said it didn't deserve above 8.0...

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932999.asp?q=Fire%20Emblem

There are many other reviews above 8.0.

I never read game magizines that only cater to one particular console because the reviews are very biased, of course Nintendo Power is going to rate Nintendo games with the highest review grade come on fire emblem is good but I dont think it deserves a 10 or a 9.5 I would see it getting a 8 or 8.5 Game Informer is one of the best magizines when it comes to reviews unlike gamespot. Game Informer gave Twiglight Princess a 10 and GS gave it a 8 come on.Melchezdek

If Game Informer gave TP a 10 and Gamespot gave it an 8 then Gamespot > Game Informer 'cause Twighlight Princess is no 10.

Well... I give it a 9.5 considering its so freakin' easy.Rocky32189

Mario games have never been hard and mario Galaxy feature some challenging levels. Have you played New Super Mario Bros and sunshine they aren't as hard as some people think. The only think that may be consider by some people hard are some of sunshines blue coins missions which are optional.

[QUOTE="Rocky32189"]Well... I give it a 9.5 considering its so freakin' easy.soulreaper-4

Mario games have never been hard and mario Galaxy feature some challenging levels. Have you played New Super Mario Bros and sunshine they aren't as hard as some people think. The only think that may be consider by some people hard are some of sunshines blue coins missions which are optional.

actually after 60 stars the game is challenging

wow they gave there own game a 9.5 thats just like the freaking national debt there is no such thing as a debt they just made it up cause there dumb ohh lets say we oh ourselves 7 trillion dollars for fun thats like saying my dog owes me 50 bucks

woot mario worse the mp3 ahhhhhh crazinessxfactor19990

Thenumber of a score doesn't mean that a game is better than other. A game thatget a 9.5 can be much better in gameplay, graphics and sound than a game that get 10. What i mean by this is that a game can get a 9.5 because the multiplayer is not very good and another can get a 10 because it doesn't have multiplayer. I hope you understand what i mean.

Nintendo Power absolutely sucks for reviews.Sants412

Yea aren't they biased?