What Paper Mario was better?

I'm comparing the first two Paper Marios so don't be like, "Where's Super Paper Mario!?" I would like to know what you guys, as gamers, like myself think which is better.

*Ending spoilers*

To me Paper Mario was better, very hard pick but listen. First off I liked Toad Town a lot better than Rougeport. Toad Town was alive and colorful where Rogueport was kinda dark and boring. I loved most of the chapters in each game so there really is no comparison between that.

I liked the story in Paper Mario the best. When I was small, I must've been like 10, my heart almost dropped when the star spirits came and helped in the final fight. Then again, it was awesome how they made the demon's soul un invincible through wishes in the Thousand Year Door.

The party in Paper Mario was more memorable then the one in TTYD. How can you forget Goombario, Bombette, or Sushi. Some of the part in TTYD were great (little Yoshi), but some were... just ehh (ex. Watt).

In the end, they were both near perfect games in my honest opinion.

Paper Mario = 9.8

Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door = 9.6

Loved both, but I think the second one edged out the first one, because of its humor, superior puzzle solving, and a well-balanced party.

Where's Super Mario RPG.:twisted: Just kidding.

Anyway, I'm going to have to go with TTYD. Why? I loved every level (I especially liked fighting my way to the top of the Professional Wrestling ladder, and I liked going to that Island...I can't remember the name of it, but you go when Bobbery first joins you. I also liked the level with those 100 little creatures that followed you...damn, I can't remember anything right now....whatever, I liked every level), the story was cool, and the characters were (for the most part) very useful...except Goombella...good-for-nothin', lousy, brickabrack! And so on.

Paper Mario is the better game ithas a better storyline partners and Toad town is far better than RP.

Paper Mario = 10(best game ever IMO)

PMTTYD = 9.7

Where's Super Mario RPG.:twisted: Just kidding.

Anyway, I'm going to have to go with TTYD. Why? I loved every level (I especially liked fighting my way to the top of the Professional Wrestling ladder, and I liked going to that Island...I can't remember the name of it, but you go when Bobbery first joins you. I also liked the level with those 100 little creatures that followed you...damn, I can't remember anything right now....whatever, I liked every level), the story was cool, and the characters were (for the most part) very useful...except Goombella...good-for-nothin', lousy, brickabrack! And so on.

bob_newman

well it depends on the pricezorau1

i'd have to go with the second...

toad town was way better and i liked the parties better

I'm just goin to cut to the chase.

IMO:
Paper Mario>>Paper Mario:TTYD>>>>>Super Paper Mario

But lets be real here, Super Mario RPG is better than all of them combined.

I've beaten Paper Mario. Loved it. Never played Ten Thousand Year Door so I vote Paper Mario.

I also got Super Paper Mario yesterday.

i think id have to say... the original. thousand year door did have some very cool parts and more bdges and stuff. and the smorg boss fight is DEFINATELY my favorite. but... the stroy in paper mario is better than ttyd. and i liked the peach parts more (i.e.- baking the cake!!!) :P

so yeah... paper mario. oh yeah! and the final fight with bowser was waaaaay better than the fight with the shadow queen.

oh yeah! P.S.- hey puppy!!! :P how you beeeeen? :D

I like both, but when reading the first post, I remembered I also had 10 years or so when I got Paper Mario and it was my first-ever RPG. It was a incredible experience.

My favorite part was cooking. Although the second one has it, I enjoyed the first one much more.

The first one is my favorite. It had a better story and party characters. And most of the places in the original were better as well. But both are great games.bededog

QFT

The first paper mario is one of the best games ever

The first one is my favorite. It had a better story and party characters. And most of the places in the original were better as well. But both are great games.bededog

Ayu avatar!

On a side note, my favorite is still the first.

oh yeah! P.S.- hey puppy!!! :P how you beeeeen? :D

PeterPerson

ugh i feel left out :( never played the first 2 paper Mario's and i dont intend too after playing Super Paper Mario i couldn't even finish it but i had my laughs here and therelolag

[QUOTE="lolag"]ugh i feel left out :( never played the first 2 paper Mario's and i dont intend too after playing Super Paper Mario i couldn't even finish it but i had my laughs here and thereSants412

[QUOTE="PeterPerson"]

oh yeah! P.S.- hey puppy!!! :P how you beeeeen? :D

Sants412

im goooood. :P

still playin strikers? i havent played that game in like a month.

[QUOTE="Sants412"][QUOTE="PeterPerson"]

oh yeah! P.S.- hey puppy!!! :P how you beeeeen? :D

PeterPerson

im goooood. :P

still playin strikers? i havent played that game in like a month.