Which game is better? Melee or Brawl

Kittens are better, meow!

I play Brawl because it's newer and has more features and such, but Melee was defintely the better core game.

I say Brawl. It's just more balanced and the new roster is just much better. Dr. Mario and Pichu won't be missed. Mewtwo and Roy on the other hand...

Still, Brawl is much more fluid and doesn't have "advanced" techniques like wavedashing. I could wavedash in Melee but it's really just glitch exploitation and it's just not very fun.

BrawlKingBowser91

Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DZumaJones07

lolwut

Brawl is much more balanced.

Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DZumaJones07

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DDark_Link142

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

Captain Falcon is way worse in Brawl :|

[QUOTE="Dark_Link142"]

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DEnglando_IV

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

Captain Falcon is way worse in Brawl :|

This

[QUOTE="Dark_Link142"]

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DEnglando_IV

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

Captain Falcon is way worse in Brawl :|

How so? The only real change I see is his new Falcon 180 Punch, which is better. His damage is slightly less and his knee a bit harder to connect, but overall, he's pretty much the same.

Perhaps it was a bit much saying he's better. He is practically the same.

crapton falcon sucked regardless. Also I think meelee was better and I MISS DR.MARIO hes was my best char. Anyway the reason meelee is better is because it didn't have a smash ball/final smash and assist trophies. Also bombs and mines powned. Screw wavedashingpoolwatcher

Captain Falcon is awesome. He's really fast and powerful. His attacks are slow but he can do some really cool combos.

Besides, you can just turn off Smash Balls/Assist trophies. I don't understand what the big deal is. Besides, assist trophies are pretty much like Pokeballs and you don't seem to have a problem with them.

crapton falcon sucked regardless. Also I think meelee was better and I MISS DR.MARIO hes was my best char. Anyway the reason meelee is better is because it didn't have a smash ball/final smash and assist trophies. Also bombs and mines powned. Screw wavedashingpoolwatcher

Falcon rocked in Melee.

I play Brawl because it's newer and has more features and such, but Melee was defintely the better core game.

Englando_IV

my thoughts exactly

Brawl. I agree with your first post, Dark_Link, but it's been proven ( through tournaments ) that Snake is the best, Falcon is the worst. Captain Falcon is a Melee character ( you even admitted he was the same ) running in the Brawl engine. In other words= :(

Snake has godly tilts. You just probably haven't played any of the pro Snake players. Luckily, I'm a DK mainer, who can defeat both him and Meta Knight easily with his amazing reach.

Captain Falcon (worst by far) ZumaJones07

tell me what you have to say after you see this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-9EG68DfvQ

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Captain Falcon (worst by far) SuperSmashBro1

tell me what you have to say after you see this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-9EG68DfvQ

Boss Battles don't mean a thing. He could have completed it without taking damage as Jigglypuff f he wanted to. Captain Falcon is at the bottom of 90% of the tier lists for a reason.

Brawl. I agree with your first post, Dark_Link, but it's been proven ( through tournaments ) that Snake is the best, Falcon is the worst. Captain Falcon is a Melee character ( you even admitted he was the same ) running in the Brawl engine. In other words= :(

Snake has godly tilts. You just probably haven't played any of the pro Snake players. Luckily, I'm a DK mainer, who can defeat both him and Meta Knight easily with his amazing reach.

toadster101

I still think Falcon is great :cry:.

And you're right. I've never faced a Snake pro.

[QUOTE="toadster101"]

Brawl. I agree with your first post, Dark_Link, but it's been proven ( through tournaments ) that Snake is the best, Falcon is the worst. Captain Falcon is a Melee character ( you even admitted he was the same ) running in the Brawl engine. In other words= :(

Snake has godly tilts. You just probably haven't played any of the pro Snake players. Luckily, I'm a DK mainer, who can defeat both him and Meta Knight easily with his amazing reach.

Dark_Link142

I still think Falcon is great :cry:.

And you're right. I've never faced a Snake pro.

I thought so too, until I almost got 3 stocked by somebody online.

[QUOTE="toadster101"]

Brawl. I agree with your first post, Dark_Link, but it's been proven ( through tournaments ) that Snake is the best, Falcon is the worst. Captain Falcon is a Melee character ( you even admitted he was the same ) running in the Brawl engine. In other words= :(

Snake has godly tilts. You just probably haven't played any of the pro Snake players. Luckily, I'm a DK mainer, who can defeat both him and Meta Knight easily with his amazing reach.

Dark_Link142

I still think Falcon is great :cry:.

And you're right. I've never faced a Snake pro.

He's not great. He has almost no priority. Hell, he's one of my favorite characters, but I can still admit that he's bad.

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DDark_Link142

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

captain falcon is betetr in brawl? oh good lord, you really don't know what you['re talking about

and snake and meta not the best? wow, now you really don't know what you;re saying do you?

[QUOTE="Dark_Link142"]

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DSonick54

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

captain falcon is betetr in brawl? oh good lord, you really don't know what you['re talking about

and snake and meta not the best? wow, now you really don't know what you;re saying do you?

Captain Falcon is the exact same as he was in Melee. Like I said, it's a Melee character in the Brawl engine.

[QUOTE="Sonick54"][QUOTE="Dark_Link142"]

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :Dtoadster101

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

captain falcon is betetr in brawl? oh good lord, you really don't know what you['re talking about

and snake and meta not the best? wow, now you really don't know what you;re saying do you?

Captain Falcon is the exact same as he was in Melee. Like I said, it's a Melee character in the Brawl engine.

and that is exactly why he is horrible now.

i say brawl,...I just wish they would fix the online -.-

[QUOTE="toadster101"][QUOTE="Sonick54"][QUOTE="Dark_Link142"]

[QUOTE="ZumaJones07"]Melee though I play Brawl because it's the new thing. Melee was a much more balanced game and catered to both competitive AND casual players - Brawl was dumbed down a bit if you ask me... and no character in Melee was as far from the rest of the roster as Snake and Metaknight (the best) and Captain Falcon (worst by far) are in Brawl. :( Both games are good though. :DSonick54

What? Captain Falcon is better in Brawl. His knee is a little harder to connect though...

Snake and Metaknight are NOT the best. I honestly don't understand what you're talking about. Besides, casual players don't stand a chance against a competitive player if wavedashing and such tricks are involved. It's much more balanced in Brawl.

captain falcon is betetr in brawl? oh good lord, you really don't know what you['re talking about

and snake and meta not the best? wow, now you really don't know what you;re saying do you?

Captain Falcon is the exact same as he was in Melee. Like I said, it's a Melee character in the Brawl engine.

and that is exactly why he is horrible now.

Yeah, we know. Read the whole thread before you post.

alright lets get off the topic of craptom fapcon who SUCKS. (that feels better) melee is better than brawl cause it revolutionized the series with Vastly improved graphics and bonus content. What brawl brought to the table is boss battles that sucked soo hard I'm surprised the wiimote didn't shoot a load at my tv screen. It also brought improved graphics but not much. But what makes melee better is that brawl stuck to the same formula as melee, it didn't revolutionize the series. It's like a RE game but not as gorey. Rest assured brawl is a great game but it's not as good as meleepoolwatcher

Also brawls cpu is dumbbed down In melee level 9's were feared, now they're almost level 6's and the unlockables, ARE USELESS, most things in brawl are just for immediate happiness. I had fun with the stage builder but to get all the parts I just made random crappoolwatcher

[QUOTE="poolwatcher"]Also brawls cpu is dumbbed down In melee level 9's were feared, now they're almost level 6's and the unlockables, ARE USELESS, most things in brawl are just for immediate happiness. I had fun with the stage builder but to get all the parts I just made random craprandomguy15

MOST UNLOCKABLES and technically you unlock almost the same amould of character and stages, most are already there

I would say something but I do not want to start another debate about about advanced techniques and stuff, so I will just say this.

At the moment, I think Melee's core gameplay is better, but Brawl has better character selection and stage selection.

HOWEVER, it should be remembered that Brawl is only 4 months old, it still has plenty of time for the metagame to develop to the caliber of melees.

Short Answer:Melee

Long Answer: It is still too early to make a call.

I would say something but I do not want to start another debate about about advanced techniques and stuff, so I will just say this.

At the moment, I think Melee's core gameplay is better, but Brawl has better character selection and stage selection.

HOWEVER, it should be remembered that Brawl is only 4 months old, it still has plenty of time for the metagame to develop to the caliber of melees.

Short Answer:Melee

Long Answer: It is still too early to make a call.

jsquared0905

brawl,more balanced characters, perfectly paced, has online play, and jam packed with a bunch of other features.inflammable01

I can't believe people keep saying that :?

Brawl is better. It has SNAAAAAAAAAKE!!

Enough said

i would say brawl because they added newer things to the series even though melee was a really good game for the nintendo gamecube.

overall brawl. its melee with so much more to do.

the only thing is that the fighting in melee felt a bit tighter and more responsive imho.

Brawl most definatly

More characters

More stages

Online play( Well that isn't Melee's fault GC just didn't have online)

Finishing moves

A more eye catching Box cover