Which is Better: Brawl or Melee?

I gotta say brawl. More and bettercharacters. Abigger single player experience. Online is good, but they should have made it differently. Me and my friends think it's better than melee. My only complaint is that the some characterssmash ball moves are too powerful, likethe Starfox characters. I got seven kills or something with one tank. Well what do you guys think? Brawl or Melee?

P.S. Don't say Melee just because Roy and Mewtwo were in it. Two people don't make the entire game amazing.

Melee is a much better game.

Brawl.

Brawl because of online play and you can make your own custom stages. :D

What do you mean by better gameplay? They both feel the same to me besides the super smashmove.

Brawl is a downgrade over Melee in every single way but the soundtrack

The controls are NERF'ed, moves were removed, the additions to the game were poorly implemented and felt tacked on, the multiplayer was broken

You can go on and on with the problems the game has

Brawl tried to be the definitive Smash Bros game but it's more of the "what not to do when making a Smash Bros game" instead

melee

Melee Please.

Well of course if youre talking about NOW, Brawl is better,

But think back of when you JUST got Melee, I felt happier playing that than brawl.

Melee + lag free online= Brawl what? that a game?

When i rentedmelee many years ago i liked it so i bought it. I didn't have the same excitement as first playing brawl. I'm always excited for a sequal to a great game. To me the excitement made it better i guess. idk

Super Smash Bros Brawl its a much bigger game with more characters.

Super Smash Bros Brawl its a much bigger game with more characters.

chocolate1325

Yes, it's bigger, but it's not better

Brawl is a downgrade over Melee in every single way but the soundtrack

The controls are NERF'ed, moves were removed, the additions to the game were poorly implemented and felt tacked on, the multiplayer was broken

You can go on and on with the problems the game has

Brawl tried to be the definitive Smash Bros game but it's more of the "what not to do when making a Smash Bros game" instead

Jaysonguy

Once again Jason is compltely right. I thought it was like playing melee with broken controls, online that takes five minutes for one on the clock to go by and the new characters had broken moves.

I guess Brawl...

Brawl, the only thing i didn't like of brawl was meta knight :P

I am going to have to say Brawl. I liked the new stages and characters. I think the event mode was way better in melee though. They both have there ups and downs but I am going with Brawl.

Brawl is better. I think Brawl gets too much hate from people who like to play Smash Bros without items and on plain stages (the so-called pros), I don't care for special techniques (bugs) that have been removed or ultra fast gameplay that allows for massive combos. I had more fun with Brawl than I had with Melee and that is all that I care for. :)

I gotta say brawl. More and bettercharacters. Abigger single player experience. Online is good, but they should have made it differently. Me and my friends think it's better than melee. My only complaint is that the some characterssmash ball moves are too powerful, likethe Starfox characters. I got seven kills or something with one tank. Well what do you guys think? Brawl or Melee?

P.S. Don't say Melee just because Roy and Mewtwo were in it. Two people don't make the entire game amazing.

I personally think that the characters in Brawl were more balanced, and almost everything was supersized and improved. Melee had its moments too but overall Brawl was better.

[QUOTE="Spectrobal"]

I gotta say brawl. More and bettercharacters. Abigger single player experience. Online is good, but they should have made it differently. Me and my friends think it's better than melee. My only complaint is that the some characterssmash ball moves are too powerful, likethe Starfox characters. I got seven kills or something with one tank. Well what do you guys think? Brawl or Melee?

P.S. Don't say Melee just because Roy and Mewtwo were in it. Two people don't make the entire game amazing.

FPS1337

Ha. Super Smash Bros Melee doesn't even have an adventure mode. Subspace Emissary is awesome,I don't get why people dislike so much.

brawl. there wasmore characters, third party characters, better stages, a better story mode, and more controller optionssman3579

Why are Sonic and Snake selling points? They are terrible. I would rather have more clones then them.

[QUOTE="sman3579"]brawl. there wasmore characters, third party characters, better stages, a better story mode, and more controller optionsrandomwiiplayer

Why are Sonic and Snake selling points? They are terrible. I would rather have more clones then them.

[QUOTE="randomwiiplayer"]

[QUOTE="sman3579"]brawl. there wasmore characters, third party characters, better stages, a better story mode, and more controller optionssman3579

Why are Sonic and Snake selling points? They are terrible. I would rather have more clones then them.

To you he is. For me he is the level of Ice Climbers and Jigglypuff. 2nd best is Link in my eyes.

What do you mean by better gameplay? They both feel the same to me besides the super smashmove.

Spectrobal

I like Brawl better. I liked the SEE and I have much more fun with Brawl then with Melee. Only problem for Brawl for me is the Classic Mode. I think the Classic Mode is better in Melee

Since I couldn't care less for competitive play and it has my favourite character in it, I would say Brawl.

My friends' that love Super Smash Bros. have different opinions. Most say Melee though, but it's around 50/50.

I say neither because I hate the games.

Melee is a lot more technical and more consequences for screwing up.Chojuto

Well if the computers didn't gang up on you in free for all matches I would say Brawl easily.

Melee,my favorite of the two so far.

Melee.

Being a competitive smasher, I find Melee to be much better. I won't enter in detail, considering that most of the people here don't know anything about competitive play, no offense, or anything.

It does has some missing elemints from Melee & original, but Brawl is better it actually has a plot.