Will MPT get a lot of 10s?

If all the separate games were AAA then shouldn't all 3 in one be AAAA?

I think this will be the best content on a single disc IMO.

It wont get a single one

The best compilation disc is located on other hardware

It wont get a single one

The best compilation disc is located on other hardware

Jaysonguy

Im curious, which would that be?

considering the orange box got good reviews

i would say atlast 9-10

If all the separate games were AAA then shouldn't all 3 in one be AAAA?

I think this will be the best content on a single disc IMO.

It wont get a single one

The best compilation disc is located on other hardware

It wont get a single one

The best compilation disc is located on other hardware

the MGS essential collection takes the number one spot, though, it is not a single disc, but the first three MGS's for $50 is awesome

the MGS essential collection takes the number one spot, though, it is not a single disc, but the first three MGS's for $50 is awesome

dragon9999970

Will it even get reviewed?

Will it even get reviewed?

TaMuK711

This may truely tell if GS is Wii Racist. Metroid Prime Trilogy is just as good as Orange Box,so they shouldrate it. However they may not.

knowing GS, itll get a 7 lolstarwarsjunky

the disk contains one of the best games of all time and to other AAA games easily a 9.5

I don't think it will get any 10s, but plenty of 9s most likely.

[QUOTE="TaMuK711"]

Will it even get reviewed?

AmayaPapaya

This may truely tell if GS is Wii Racist. Metroid Prime Trilogy is just as good as Orange Box,so they shouldrate it. However they may not.

Seriously, if the game even gets reviewed anything under a 9/10 would be downright wrong. For the same price you got Prime 3 (8.5) plus two improved versions of 9+/10 games.

It will probably get a 9 or 9.5 seeing how the Orange Box got reviews around there.

You could review it two different ways:

1. If you've never played them before, 9.5-10

2. If you've played them already, 8.5-9.0

Although with each of them you do have to consider budget pricing as well as some dated graphics. And of course new Wiimote control and Widescreen 480p on the first two.

knowing GS, itll get a 7 lolstarwarsjunky

Nah, that's too high for it. Lmfao.

It wont get a single one

The best compilation disc is located on other hardware

Jaysonguy

i already sold my copy of MP3 in anticipation of this since ive never played 1 or 2...

EDIT: has anyone heard if you can use MP3 save files?

Jayson is probably talking about the Genesis collectionlink027

[QUOTE="link027"]Jayson is probably talking about the Genesis collectionfreakbabyblues

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

It wont get a single one

The best compilation disc is located on other hardware

-Oath

Im curious, which would that be?

I'm guessing he's talking about the Orange Box. That's the only one I can think of that's highly regarded by the gaming community.

Will it even get reviewed?TaMuK711

Well seeing as most compilations like this have never been reviewed, I'm gonna say chances are slim.

I love how Jaysonguy always just leaves a comment to get everyone worked up for no reason and usually doesn't come back. That's the definition of a troll. He was probably talking about Super Mario Allstars or Orange Box anyway.

I don't think many sites will review MPT because its basically 3 older games which have already been reviewed and haven't been improved much.

If they review it here it should be anAAA, but who knows, they may give it the usual Wii's 7-7.5.

What's the point of reviewing it? They already reviewed all 3 games separately.OreoMilkshake

The only reason I can think of would because of the first two games, which have been adapted for the Wii. But even then, I don't think that alone would warrant a full review. If anything, they'll probably make a post on the Reviews Blog about it.

Yeah I imagine it will. Not from Gamespot, from from other sites.

[QUOTE="OreoMilkshake"]What's the point of reviewing it? They already reviewed all 3 games separately.c_rake

The only reason I can think of would because of the first two games, which have been adapted for the Wii. But even then, I don't think that alone would warrant a full review. If anything, they'll probably make a post on the Reviews Blog about it.

It depends on what motion controls they threw into it. I mean if they added the pointer and that's pretty much it, I might pick it up just for fun (despite having all three already)... but if they tacked on motion controls for the sake of saying: "Look Metroid Prime now has Motion controls!" I won't bother at all. As such, I think most reviewers will be in the same camp. 9.5's or lower. It's hard to give something that was last gen with minor modifications a 10.raahsnavj

knowing GS, itll get a 7 lolstarwarsjunky

Well, I think it will be reviewed, but I doubt it's going to get a single *professional* "10." Considering the fact that even IGN gave RE4 a 9 on the Wii, I doubt MPT is going to score any higher.

The only chance this game has of scoring a perfect 10 is if they throw in a TON of cool extras and/or sell the whole package for $30 . . . and that's only if the reviewer decides to go for a "bang for your buck" score inflation.

As long as the ports are solid and the new controls work well, I think this will get a lot of 8's and 9's. All that is moot, anyway, since I'm buying it regardless. :)

there's no reason it should get a 10. That would be like giving Twilight Princess (GC) a 9, and (Wii) a 10. They're the same game (minus the contols)

MP3 didn't get a 10 and absolutely nothing changed.

The only changes that were made were to the first 2 games and it was the controls, 16:9and bloom lighting. WOW!!! that makes it brand new!

the story is exactly the same.....

I'm not trying to knock it, it's definitely a must buy imo, but I'm not expecting it to be better than what it was before. They were already good in the first place

there's no reason it should get a 10. That would be like giving Twilight Princess (GC) a 9, and (Wii) a 10. They're the same game (minus the contols)

MP3 didn't get a 10 and absolutely nothing changed.

The only changes that were made were to the first 2 games and it was the controls, 16:9and bloom lighting. WOW!!! that makes it brand new!

the story is exactly the same.....

I'm not trying to knock it, it's definitely a must buy imo, but I'm not expecting it to be better than what it was before. They were already good in the first place

danger_ranger95

back to jayson's "favorite compilation" :P (sorry, it's just that apparently everyone forgot this one, and it just came to my mind :P)

Zelda: collectors edition anyone?

No way, remakes rarely get 10's which is kind of disappointing sometimes when a remake of an old, great game comes out and recieves not so great reviews which makes it seem crappier than it is, I mean, Gamespot gave Chrono Trigger DS an 8.5, it's much, much better than an 8.5.