Black Swan vs Fight Club

Cards on the table people, which one was better?. I'd have to say black swan. Fight club was a good movie but for me it was a bit too silly at times and a little overrated. Black swan had me fully engaged throughout the whole movie.

Black Swan!

I like Fight Club more, but I can acknowledge that Black Swan is the better film.

This.

I love Fight Club alot.

I find this comparison silly, and am in disbelief if anyone votes Black Swan over it, thats how much I like it.

I'm not sure why we are choosing between these two movies, but of them I think I like Black Swan more.

You bloody fool! Don't you know the ninth rule of Fight Club? Do not compare Fight Club to Black Swan :evil:

I like Fight Club more, but I can acknowledge that Black Swan is the better film.

Oleg_Huzwog

Black Swan wins by default because of [spoiler] lesbians [/spoiler]

Black Swan wins by default because of [spoiler] lesbians [/spoiler] McainTehNub

to be fair, that never actually happened :P

why the f*** are you comparing themJandurin

Because of the similar plot twists, I assume.

That's a very odd combination.

[QUOTE="Jandurin"]why the f*** are you comparing themOleg_Huzwog

Because of the similar plot twists, I assume.

basically, the movies had nothing in common but using a similar mechanism to drive whatever they were pushingJandurin

Cards on the table people, which one was better?. I'd have to say black swan. Fight club was a good movie but for me it was a bit too silly at times and a little overrated. Black swan had me fully engaged throughout the whole movie.

killerboi2

Well I havent seen Black Swan, but I do love the film Fight Club but I love the novel even more.

Black Swan is the better film, but you can probably figure out the ending before it's even half-way through if you're familiar with the director.

Plus Mila Kunis is hawt.

Black Swan was an amazing movie, but overall I enjoyed Fight Club more

Didn't care for Fight Club at all, the movie was decent up to the plot twist which ruined it all....:|

I haven't seen Black Swan so I can't comment on it.

Cards on the table people, which one was better?. I'd have to say black swan. Fight club was a good movie but for me it was a bit too silly at times and a little overrated. Black swan had me fully engaged throughout the whole movie.

killerboi2

why the f*** are you comparing themJandurin

I love them both, but I have to go with Fight Club because it is more manly lol. Plus I know it way better cause I read the book as well. It is too bad that most guys will ignore Black Swan because they think it is about ballet, which it really isn't.

Both! Black Swan as a film but I enjoy Fight Club more.

[QUOTE="killerboi2"]

Cards on the table people, which one was better?. I'd have to say black swan. Fight club was a good movie but for me it was a bit too silly at times and a little overrated. Black swan had me fully engaged throughout the whole movie.

lightleggy

Fight club all the way, mainly because It's a movie I can see with other people confortably and have a nice laugh. I went to see Black Swan with my ex and her parents and there were some scenes that just.....made it reeaally awkard to be in that theater. But other than that black swan is still a terrific filmDarthkaiser

Well, to be fair, I watched Black Swan with my friend and it was fun. We had many laughs throughout, even though it wasn't a comedy. Really good movie.

[QUOTE="Darthkaiser"]Fight club all the way, mainly because It's a movie I can see with other people confortably and have a nice laugh. I went to see Black Swan with my ex and her parents and there were some scenes that just.....made it reeaally awkard to be in that theater. But other than that black swan is still a terrific filmSharpie125

Well, to be fair, I watched Black Swan with my friend and it was fun. We had many laughs throughout, even though it wasn't a comedy. Really good movie.

Fight Club, Black Swan was too much of a mind****Apocalypse33

[QUOTE="Apocalypse33"]Fight Club, Black Swan was too much of a mind****CosmoKing7717

Fight Club all the way.

Fight Club of course. Black Swan is good, but it doesn't have that lasting power for me or that same replayability Fight Club has. I just want to show everyone FC if they haven't seen it.