[QUOTE="theone86"]
[QUOTE="Andrew_Xavier"]
Nolan has had some amazing films: Memento, Insomnia, Batman Series
Some good films: The Prestige...well one good film :P
And some bloody awful films: Inception, Following.
But, is he the greatest director of this generation? No. Lynch, Cronenberg, Tarantino (yeah, it's cool to hate tarantino now, but he makes amazing movies.), Aronofsky, Edgar Wright, Scorsese, Chan-wook Park, Joel Coen...
Also, I don't believe anyone is this generation's Kubrick...No one really has the same style of directing that he did, so it's truly an odd thing to claim.
Andrew_Xavier
Insomnia, amazing? Really? And the Batman films as well?
Okay, called Inception and Following awful, stopped taking seriously.
Mentioned Tarantino, Edgar Wright, and David Cronenberg as some of the best of our generation, definitely stopped taking seriuosly.
Inception was awful. Ham-fisted crap. Unoriginal concept, I preferred the version Cronenberg did a decade before. It might have been good...if you know, it didn't scream "THIS IS THE POINT OF THE FILM GUYS, K????????" every 5 bloody seconds. As I mentioned, it's cool to hate Tarantino now. He still makes fantastic films. I defy you to name a director better than Cronenberg. There are a few who have made exceptional films, Julie Taymor made likely the greatest film of all time...but across the universe was bloody awful...Also, I get it, the Batman trilogy is very popular, we aren't psuedo-hipster enough if we don't hate it :P
Okay, Kubrick. Or did you mean a more modern director? Coen, Scorcese, hell, I prefer Nolan to him. History of Violence was completely overrated, and Eastern Promises was good but nothing amazing. Crash, way overrated. The man is probably the second most overrated director after Tarantino. I like most of Tarantino's work, liked Resevoir Dogs, Kill Bill, and Inglorious Basterds, but they're still overrated. The man's a one-dimensional director. His best film to date has been Pulp Fiction, and he seems to have peaked there. Fantastic? That's a real stretch.
Oh, it's hipster to hate the Batman trilogy now? I remember when it was hipster to say TDK was the best movie of all time. Frankly, I don't rightly care about what's cool to hate and like, I form my own opinions of movies. The Batman movies were good, but nowhere near as good as people make them out to be. Amazing? Come on. Citizen Kane is amazing, North by Northwest is amazing, the Batman films are really only pretty good action movies. TDK may be one of the best action movies made, in fact, but it's still mostly an excuse to see big explosions, cool vehicles, and exciting fight scenes. If that's the criteria for amazing I could find dozens of films that qualify.
Log in to comment