Dark Side of the Moon vs. The Wall

Just curious, that's all. I consider these some of the greatest rock albums of all time. What do you say?

i voted dark side, not easy to separate the two.

WYWH > Animals > TDOTM >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Wall

DSOTM is way better.

The wall overall though Wish you were here, and Meddle are better than both.

whenever i see someone in one of those generic darkside of the moon shirts, i automatically assume they are a PF poser. i once asked a guy what his fav song on darkside was ( cuz he was wearing the shirt) and he said " uh... another brick in the wall) ..nimatoad2000

whenever i see someone in one of those generic darkside of the moon shirts, i automatically assume they are a PF poser. i once asked a guy what his fav song on darkside was ( cuz he was wearing the shirt) and he said " uh... another brick in the wall) ..nimatoad2000

This is like asking me to pick between chocolate cake and pumpkin pie. :cry:

This is like asking me to pick between chocolate cake and pumpkin pie. :cry:

GabuEx

[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"]whenever i see someone in one of those generic darkside of the moon shirts, i automatically assume they are a PF poser. i once asked a guy what his fav song on darkside was ( cuz he was wearing the shirt) and he said " uh... another brick in the wall) ..CoolSkAGuy

Dark side of those two albums now called CD's.

roulettethedog

Dark Side of the moon when I got it as a album (yes I'm old) It came with great posters and2 stickers..

I voted for The Wall. It was a tough choice.

This one is easy.

Wish You Were Here.

whenever i see someone in one of those generic darkside of the moon shirts, i automatically assume they are a PF poser. i once asked a guy what his fav song on darkside was ( cuz he was wearing the shirt) and he said " uh... another brick in the wall) ..nimatoad2000

I just can't say one is better than the other, they're both excellent. Sorry :(

whenever i see someone in one of those generic darkside of the moon shirts, i automatically assume they are a PF poser. i once asked a guy what his fav song on darkside was ( cuz he was wearing the shirt) and he said " uh... another brick in the wall) ..nimatoad2000

It's a three-way tie for me, Dark Side of the Moon, Animals, and Wish you Were Here. The Wall is overrated.

Dark Side of the Moon by far, The Wall was good but I thought the lyrics overpowered the rest of the music.

The Wall is better but I'd rather listen to Wish You Were Here or Meddle.

TDSoTM for me. Although IMO Animals beats them both :Pcyberdarkkid

are you aware that most albums are still released on vinyl? nimatoad2000

I don't like either of them, but I guess I'll go with Dark Side of the Moon. I'm not big on Pink Floyd, though I do LOVE The Piper at the Gates of Dawn!

The Wall, by volume of good tracksalone, but I guess not everyone would see it that way. DSotM is more consistently good, but I still feel The Wall has more good tracks. It is a bit a whine though.

I have a strong strong dislike of Animals, but both that andWish You Were Here should be included in this comparison. Quite often people like that one the most. In my opinion it dosn't really have enough songs to justify beating DSotM, but whatever, some people will just prefer it. As for Animals, I'm not even going to go there. It's even more whiney than The Wall, only with alot less content.

Wish You Were Here and Animals both are A LOT better then those two.