This topic is locked from further discussion.
Only during situations when it's needed or appropriate. For example, if someone has a disease that will with out a doubt kill them in a horrible way and they have to suffer an incredible amount of pain, it's very appropriate to use it. However, if someone simply wants to kill them self because they have depression, it shouldn't be used.Media_geek20But people who are mentally down, and are eager to kill themselves have a lot of pain and a lot of suffering to do mentally. And if they have the chance to kill themselves, they will. I don't see the point of keeping those people locked against their will till they die out of age. I'd say that a psychiatrist needs to approve in those cases, cause he will know better then anyone if there is hope for recuperation.
[QUOTE="Media_geek20"]Only during situations when it's needed or appropriate. For example, if someone has a disease that will with out a doubt kill them in a horrible way and they have to suffer an incredible amount of pain, it's very appropriate to use it. However, if someone simply wants to kill them self because they have depression, it shouldn't be used.Sensui1986But people who are mentally down, and are eager to kill themselves have a lot of pain and a lot of suffering to do mentally. And if they have the chance to kill themselves, they will. I don't see the point of keeping those people locked against their will till they die out of age. I'd say that a psychiatrist needs to approve in those cases, cause he will know better then anyone if there is hope for recuperation.
Someone always beats me to it :(. Yes, I think the youth in Asia have every right we do. Old people should be allowed to kill themselves too. There are going to be way too many of them now that the baby boomers are getting older. Much better they just off themselves, than have to pay a bizillion dollars in taxes to support them.
Sure, why not?
Ninety-2
[QUOTE="Ninety-2"]Someone always beats me to it :(. Yes, I think the youth in Asia have every right we do. Old people should be allowed to kill themselves too. There are going to be way too many of them now that the baby boomers are getting older. Much better they just off themselves, than have to pay a bizillion dollars in taxes to support them. That's a bad way of reasoning if you ask me. Do you like the youth to think of you like that when you are old?
Sure, why not?
Yarcofin
I approve on many terms such as if you are disabled beyond doing much "fun" in your life.
I do not agree with it if:
1) Your going to hurt others, your family probably love you and so would many others around you it is easier on everyone to rehabilitate rather than simply end your life.
2) You have a duty (cowardice), for example, in a war like WW2 I have read and heard of some cowards that committed suicide rather than helping others through the war.
Before some morons start having a go at me for "Oh you didn't know how it was", I can tell you that the people who survived it would slap you into the next world war.
I am sure there are other points, but my mind has gone dry.
In the case of someone saying straight up "I want to die." Yes 100%. When it comes to people in a vegitative state it's less clear cut (unless they have a living will). Thats when you really have to stop and think what would that person want. Deciding if someone should live or die is really a decision that only that person should make.Private_Vegas
I think your idea of anyone who says I want to die is utterly ridiculous.
Many people fall in and out of depression and at times when they want to die, they should be denied since they will usually soon want to live again.Â
As for people in a vegetative state then I believe there should be some sort of check that people do when they are 18, this includes whether they wish for a donor card, will they donate blood ect. and will they wish to die peacefully if they are in this state. Up to the point of 18 I believe it is the responsibility of the parents or guardians, simply because they will be the next best people to know what is correct for you.
Only during situations when it's needed or appropriate. For example, if someone has a disease that will with out a doubt kill them in a horrible way and they have to suffer an incredible amount of pain, it's very appropriate to use it. However, if someone simply wants to kill them self because they have depression, it shouldn't be used.Media_geek20I agree......while i do not think that it's right because a person might perceive a sick person in a way that would justify killing them, when they might get better.........it could just get out of control if left to the wrong person.
For those who don't know:The way you say it yes, but when its about animals just because there are to many, no
Euthanasia comes from the greek words "eu" and "thanatos" what means "good death".
Euthanasia is actually ensuring a painless death to someone who is suffering a lot, or has a uncurable disease, and is willing to die before he get's the unpleasant effects of that disease.
Euthanasia normally is the will of the person who is going to die, but in some cases it's not, as the family and the doctor can also approve it when the patients is in no condition to speak or to think.
Anyway...
I think it should be approved when the patient is accepting it.
Or when someone is living like a plant, not being able to speak, move are having joy in life, I think that when the doctor and the family agrees, it should be possible too.
We also sometimes kill animals to stop their suffering, everyone approves that.
Why can't human beings have that privilege too if they want?
Discuss
Sensui1986
Of course not. Every person has a right to live.murlow12So matter how much pain they are in they shouldn't have the right to do what they want with their body?
[QUOTE="murlow12"]Of course not. Every person has a right to live.yoshi-lnexSo matter how much pain they are in they shouldn't have the right to do what they want with their body? I don't believe in keeping someone alive with machines at all, so I don't think we disagree here. In other words, I disagree with any type of forced death. But if they were never on life support in the first place, then their shouldn't be an issue.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment