Give me one modern artist/group who can replicate this album.

Paul McCartney-Ram

Figured since people claim modern artists are just as good as classic ones, then it wouldn't be too difficult to find one that can replicate this album/do it better.

Jeff Mangum

/Thread

Jeff Mangum

/Thread

CHOASXIII

How would repliating an album be as good?

How would repliating an album be as good?

ScorpionTroll

He meant having someone sing it just as good not particually replicate it completely.

How would repliating an album be as good?

ScorpionTroll

There are modern artists/groups that can make a better album.

I don't know how "replicating" that album would make a great artist. Seems like that would just make whoever did the replicating a good cover band.:?

Paul McCartney-Ram

Figured since people claim modern artists are just as good as classic ones, then it wouldn't be too difficult to find one that can replicate this album/do it better.

jesuschristmonk

definitely not my favorite McCartney album.

but anyway, blues travelers could probably do a pretty good, if not interesting job of it.

I don't know how "replicating" that album would make a great artist. Seems like that would just make whoever did the replicating a good cover band.:?

Assassin_87

Exactly.

That album is not even that good. You could have atleast used Band on the Run (not that that would have made this thread much better).

That album is not even that good. You could have atleast used Band on the Run (not that that would have made this thread much better).

GreySeal9

Lol

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

That album is not even that good. You could have atleast used Band on the Run (not that that would have made this thread much better).

CHOASXIII

Lol

Do you think Ram is better than Band on the Run?

Stupid premise. Stupid thread.

Stupid premise. Stupid thread.

worlock77

As dumb as the premise is, I still don't understand why he would base the thread on such a mediocre album.

[QUOTE="CHOASXIII"]

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

That album is not even that good. You could have atleast used Band on the Run (not that that would have made this thread much better).

GreySeal9

Lol

Do you think Ram is better than Band on the Run?

Never listened to Band on the Run other than "Band on the Run". Besides Ram was a solo album and I like the rawness of it.

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

[QUOTE="CHOASXIII"]

Lol

CHOASXIII

Do you think Ram is better than Band on the Run?

Never listened to Band on the Run other than "Band on the Run". Besides Ram was a solo album and I like the rawness of it.

I basically count Wings album as Paul McCartney albums since the other members of the band never really had any creative imput.

I don't like Ram because it is part of the period where McCartney was pumping out nothing but half-assed ditties. IMO, songs like Band on the Run, Jet, Let Me Roll It, etc. kill anything on Ram.

[QUOTE="worlock77"]

Stupid premise. Stupid thread.

GreySeal9

As dumb as the premise is, I still don't understand why he would base the thread on such a mediocre album.

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

[QUOTE="worlock77"]

Stupid premise. Stupid thread.

CondorCalabasas

As dumb as the premise is, I still don't understand why he would base the thread on such a mediocre album.

I shouldn't even answer you because you're just being bitter as usual but I'll try to explain to you, using words that hopefully won't hurt your head too much, why the choice of album is important.

Before we start, you'll need to put your thinking cap on:

If one is making a thread based on the merit of old music acts, then it pays to actually use an album that is known to be one of the defining albums of its era. Paul McCartney's Ram album is not one of those.

[QUOTE="CHOASXIII"]

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

Do you think Ram is better than Band on the Run?

GreySeal9

Never listened to Band on the Run other than "Band on the Run". Besides Ram was a solo album and I like the rawness of it.

I basically count Wings album as Paul McCartney albums since the other members of the band never really had any creative imput.

I don't like Ram because it is part of the period where McCartney was pumping out nothing but half-assed ditties. IMO, songs like Band on the Run, Jet, Let Me Roll It, etc. kill anything on Ram.

Meh, either way I will give my opinion on the other ones when I hear the other ones.

[QUOTE="CondorCalabasas"][QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

As dumb as the premise is, I still don't understand why he would base the thread on such a mediocre album.

GreySeal9

I shouldn't even answer you because you're just being bitter as usual but I'll try to explain to you, using words that hopefully won't hurt your head too much, why the choice of album is important.

Before we start, you'll need to put your thinking cap on:

If one is making a thread based on the merit of old music acts, then it pays to actually use an album that is known to be one of the defining albums of its era. Paul McCartney's Ram album is not one of those.

I don't know of anyone who considers 'Ram' to really be anything more than a footnote in McCartney's career.

[QUOTE="CondorCalabasas"][QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

As dumb as the premise is, I still don't understand why he would base the thread on such a mediocre album.

GreySeal9

I shouldn't even answer you because you're just being bitter as usual but I'll try to explain to you, using words that hopefully won't hurt your head too much, why the choice of album is important.

Before we start, you'll need to put your thinking cap on:

If one is making a thread based on the merit of old music acts, then it pays to actually use an album that is known to be one of the defining albums of its era. Paul McCartney's Ram album is not one of those.

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

[QUOTE="CondorCalabasas"] If you think the thread and the premise is so "stupid" then why do you care so much about what album? Contradicting yourself.worlock77

I shouldn't even answer you because you're just being bitter as usual but I'll try to explain to you, using words that hopefully won't hurt your head too much, why the choice of album is important.

Before we start, you'll need to put your thinking cap on:

If one is making a thread based on the merit of old music acts, then it pays to actually use an album that is known to be one of the defining albums of its era. Paul McCartney's Ram album is not one of those.

I don't know of anyone who considers 'Ram' to really be anything more than a footnote in McCartney's career.

I don't either. To me, Ram was not a serious effort. Like the album before it and two albums after it, I think Ram was more about McCartney just letting out some creative energy.

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

[QUOTE="CondorCalabasas"] If you think the thread and the premise is so "stupid" then why do you care so much about what album? Contradicting yourself.CondorCalabasas

I shouldn't even answer you because you're just being bitter as usual but I'll try to explain to you, using words that hopefully won't hurt your head too much, why the choice of album is important.

Before we start, you'll need to put your thinking cap on:

If one is making a thread based on the merit of old music acts, then it pays to actually use an album that is known to be one of the defining albums of its era. Paul McCartney's Ram album is not one of those.

Okay. Fine. I'm contradicting myself. Now can you please go away so we can talk about music without having to sift through your bitter posts?

[QUOTE="ScorpionTroll"]

How would repliating an album be as good?

jesuschristmonk

[QUOTE="ScorpionTroll"]

How would repliating an album be as good?

jesuschristmonk

[QUOTE="GreySeal9"]

[QUOTE="CondorCalabasas"] If you think the thread and the premise is so "stupid" then why do you care so much about what album? Contradicting yourself.worlock77

I shouldn't even answer you because you're just being bitter as usual but I'll try to explain to you, using words that hopefully won't hurt your head too much, why the choice of album is important.

Before we start, you'll need to put your thinking cap on:

If one is making a thread based on the merit of old music acts, then it pays to actually use an album that is known to be one of the defining albums of its era. Paul McCartney's Ram album is not one of those.

I don't know of anyone who considers 'Ram' to really be anything more than a footnote in McCartney's career.

so many posts and im the only one answered the question....can i have a medal?

Noel Gallagher could replicate it, but as others have said...why?

Gary Numen could provide an interesting take on it...

Lights >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Everything else.

[QUOTE="ScorpionTroll"]

How would repliating an album be as good?

jesuschristmonk

I'm pretty sure it's the other way around.

TC has horrible taste in music.

ASKING ALEXANDRIA! Why? Because they are "hardcore, drinkers and can do anything! Cause they're harda$$'s!" ...codymcclain14

[QUOTE="codymcclain14"] ASKING ALEXANDRIA! Why? Because they are "hardcore, drinkers and can do anything! Cause they're harda$$'s!" ...shadowkiller11

Keeping it in somewhat similar vein? Probably The Black Keys.