Hypothetical Question: Would you go out with your best friend's sister?

This has happened to me before but I fought my feelings and now I'm actually her friend. Would you ever go out with your best friend's sister/brother? Seems kinda weird to me, but then again, I've heard lots of crazy things today. xD

Hmm....

Sure.

No, I would never, ever consider such an abominable betrayal of my friendship!Theokhoth

How is that betrayal? You're bound to get to know her better and if there's a connection between the two, then why not go for it?

Okay, so I've heard 2 yeses and 1 no so far. Imagine if you're having sex with your best friend's sister and he walks in the room. How would you feel?HardcoreBunni

A little awkward. But eh...

[QUOTE="Theokhoth"]No, I would never, ever consider such an abominable betrayal of my friendship!Genetic_Code

How is that betrayal? You're bound to get to know her better and if there's a connection between the two, then why not go for it?

I actually DID go out with my best friend's sister. He was fine with it, and me and her were really good friends for almost 2 years. Didn't work out though, the whole distance thing got in the way.

Okay, so I've heard 2 yeses and 1 no so far. Imagine if you're having sex with your best friend's sister and he walks in the room. How would you feel?HardcoreBunni

Well, I would wonder why we didn't lock the door.

If I liked her and she liked me...sure. Why not?luke1889

Just as a heads up, I think older brothers are obligated to hate their sister's boyfriends.

[QUOTE="luke1889"]If I liked her and she liked me...sure. Why not?Dark_Knight6

Just as a heads up, I think older brothers are obligated to hate their sister's boyfriends.

[QUOTE="luke1889"]If I liked her and she liked me...sure. Why not?Dark_Knight6

Just as a heads up, I think older brothers are obligated to hate their sister's boyfriends.

Haha, well, you can abide by your own obligations then. :P

I can totally understand your concern though. :oops:

This has happened to me before but I fought my feelings and now I'm actually her friend. Would you ever go out with your best friend's sister/brother? Seems kinda weird to me, but then again, I've heard lots of crazy things today. xD

HardcoreBunni

Given up on the girl you sneezed on?

Actually when you think about this, what's wrong with it in the first place?

If it's your best friend, most likey both of you think eachother to be great guys. So who would be a more fitting BF for your dear sister than your greatest friend who is an awesome person?
Why is it insulting rather than being happy for your sister and friend?
Perhaps in real-life it's a bit more complicated but when you look at it that way..

_e

It might be just me, but I honestly don't care who my sister's boyfriend is. As long as he isnt a tool or anything its fine. She is 12 though...Hook-a-holic

I've hated every single one of my sister's boyfriends, the guy she is with now is a complete *** hole and he's ugly. But, she could just have bad-taste in guys. :P

[QUOTE="HardcoreBunni"]

This has happened to me before but I fought my feelings and now I'm actually her friend. Would you ever go out with your best friend's sister/brother? Seems kinda weird to me, but then again, I've heard lots of crazy things today. xD

McManus107

Given up on the girl you sneezed on?

Nah, this goes way back. Like 2 years ago or something when I was in the 8th grade. I'm still hopeful that I'll manage to make ammends with the whole sneeze issue. I'll post the outcome on monday only in the Off-Topic Forum.

Better she goes out with me than some guy my friend doesn't know or trust.foxhound_fox

Okay, so I've heard 2 yeses and 1 no so far. Imagine if you're having sex with your best friend's sister and he walks in the room. How would you feel?HardcoreBunni

First off yes I would go out with my best friends sister if she was hot and if he walked in on me that would be veryawkward.

Okay, so I've heard 2 yeses and 1 no so far. Imagine if you're having sex with your best friend's sister and he/she walks in the room. How would you feel?HardcoreBunni

I don't know, it depends really on what my friend thinks about it. If they didn't mind, then certainly, yes, otherwise... I'm not so sure.

Okay, so I've heard 2 yeses and 1 no so far. Imagine if you're having sex with your best friend's sister and he walks in the room. How would you feel?HardcoreBunni

wait........

I would wonder why he is walking into his sister's room unannounced and with no knocking.

I don't think so. I consider best friend to be something really extraordinary since I don't consider any of my friends that.

I'm 14 and she's 16, she has a boyfriend and she is really hot.

I'm going to have to make an assassination plan...

Any thoughts?

Yup