[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"]
No wonder Trent quit touring....:o
Samwel_X
I will always hold Portrait with relatively high regard. I liked it musically and lyrically, the image was just an image, rather than it bleeding into the music. Plus, killer production.
Antichrist Superstar... is my least favorite of the (what I think are) decent Manson albums, it is in places a little silly in its concept. But there are some songs on it I really like, but also some that I don't, plus, Trent's production (and a wee bit of musicianship) makes it automatically be in my good books.
Mechanical Animals, for the most part was just a good listen. Some songs were very stupid lyrically, but still just a good bit of fun I guess.
Had he put out say, 11 song albums they would have been musically better than they are, kick off the filler. The other problem was that the image bled too far into the band, making the band the image, rather than the music... if that makes sense. It was almost as if, the spur of the moment shocks that came early on, or more the gimmick, became forced, and now that he is doing it and he is 40 it is just plain sad. With one "shocking" thing after another it just appears to be a desperate attempt to stay in the public eye. An occasional thing, fine, but I suppose the band became built up on that reputation and it swallowed them whole. Then the band became that reputation and relied on it rather than producing anything of substance.
That's the way I see it at least. Again, I can't really listen to his music any more, I just feel rather silly doing so, it is somewhat juvenile, of course, it is important to be aware, even in my mouth my interest in Manson only existed because of my interest in Trent, hence, post Trent (aside from MA) I sever all interest, I have checked out his work since then, and it has been pretty crappy...
Killer production on the first 3 albums though :p
What the hell is wrong with the lyrics? They have some of the finest wordplay out there. When people talk about Mansons image the often don't understand that Antichrist Superstar, Mechanical Animals and HolyWood are all CONCEPT ALBUMS. Manson is playing a character in those three. Notice that after the Golden Age Of Grotesque Manson focused less on shock rock.If those albums suck than so does The Downward Spiral and The Fragile.
Log in to comment