Yeah! So whats the best gangster film of those 4? Please post why you think such film is better. :D
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Reservoir dogs seems to be a little out of place.... I still voted for it, because when I come to power as the Supreme World Leader and purge humanity of the unworthy, Tarantino will be the only movie director I will keep alive.
PS The first vote was MINE!!! My road to domination begins!!!!!
[QUOTE="XanderKage"]
Reservoir dogs seems to be a little out of place....
JML897
For sure. The Godfather & Once Upon a Time in America fit with the other choices a lot better.
Out of the list, I choose Goodfellas.
Well I believe that both of those are great films that would probably blow the other options away if I had included them in the poll... so I just excluded them. We all know that they are awesome crime films. Thats what I dislike the Rotten Tomatoes 5 favorite films collum.. people always mention the same movies. So why not include other movies in this poll? :PActually, I HAVE seen Chinatown... good film. I am still sticking with Casino though. Chinatown is more film noir for me.I have never seen Chinatown... so out of the remaining three, I would have to say Casino.
entropyecho
Scarface is better than Godfather People keep talking about Scarface so some years ago I saw it... It wasn't as great as many people say. It is a good movie, i wont deny that, but It just overrated. It can also be said that it was really long. :P[QUOTE="immortality20"]
Out of those, Goodfellas. But nothing beats Godfather.
x8VXU6
[QUOTE="x8VXU6"]Scarface is better than Godfather People keep talking about Scarface so some years ago I saw it... It wasn't as great as many people say. It is a good movie, i wont deny that, but It just overrated. It can also be said that it was really long. :Pand u think the godfather is short[QUOTE="immortality20"]
Out of those, Goodfellas. But nothing beats Godfather.
MrEnvelope
I went with Chinatown because to me it's by far the best film of the bunch. Casino doesn't rank with me because it's just a less-good attempt at recreating former glories. Reservoir Dogs (like Scarface) gets way way more credit than it comes close to deserving. Goodfellas is pretty damn good, but a bit too aware of itself. Chinatown is just a confident, impressive showing from start to finish.
People keep talking about Scarface so some years ago I saw it... It wasn't as great as many people say. It is a good movie, i wont deny that, but It just overrated. It can also be said that it was really long. :Pand u think the godfather is short The Godfather is a longer and superior movie than Scarface. I felt that Scarface dragged for a while in several parts.[QUOTE="MrEnvelope"][QUOTE="x8VXU6"]Scarface is better than Godfather
x8VXU6
Goodfellas was an excellent movie. I also enjoyed Casino as the actors stuck with their character role; Deniro as a calm and collected mobster and Pesci as a wild out of control pyschopath. savetehhaloz
Goodfellas easily. Its got an amazing ensemble with some sweet cameos and sick direction.
Reservoir Dogs suffers from QT only wanting to hear his actors talk.
Casino would be my second choice but it seems kinda dragged out at times.
Chinatown still need to finish it.
But my favorite crime films: The Godfather 1&2, City of God.
[QUOTE="savetehhaloz"]Goodfellas was an excellent movie. I also enjoyed Casino as the actors stuck with their character role; Deniro as a calm and collected mobster and Pesci as a wild out of control pyschopath. Samurai_Xavier
Casino isn't overrated, because other than this poll/thread, no one gives it much credit at all.
Goodfellas is the best movie I've ever seen. What's really amazing is that it's all true.
VigilanteArtist
Clearly you've never seen Poolhall Junkies.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment