Starwars vs. StarTrek

Which do you like better?

So it's this:

V.S. this:

Easily, starwars for me.

Star Wars, I never got into Star Trek but I'll most likely enjoy it later in life...unless you mean the new film.

Star Wars easily. Why no poll?xTheExploited

Star Wars, I never got into Star Trek but I'll most likely enjoy it later in life...unless you mean the new film.

cyborg100000

I prefer Star Trek, I like SW but it's too fantasy-like for me, I know Star Trek isn't completely realistic but at least it tries.

All the people saying Star Trek has better science, the science of both series are equally wrong and implausible.

Star Trek!!!!!!!! :Dt3hrubikscube

Star Wars for Darth Vader, Han Solo and the Force!! (and that one moment when I was a kid and first heard "I am your father." That is perhaps the most memorable moment in movie history from my childhood...) The trilogy was just epic.

Only have seen the newest Trek. It was pretty solid. Better than the new Star Wars flicks IMO, but had nothing on the originals.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rYhRqf757I

Star Trek!

Come on. They CAN'T be compared. Completely different universes with completely different formats for storytelling. They both have things that are absolutely amazing about them, and they both have aspects that absolutely suck about both of them.

Ever wanted to know how a Klingon lures a mate?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzhhXZ5kp7A&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rYhRqf757I

Star Trek!

I prefer Star Trek (specifically The Next Generation). I always found Star Wars to be boring and somewhat inconsistent.

Star Trek wins because Star Wars doesn't have "Nuclear wessels".

Star Trek wins because Star Wars doesn't have "Nuclear wessels".

MetroidPrimePwn

[QUOTE="MetroidPrimePwn"]

Star Trek wins because Star Wars doesn't have "Nuclear wessels".

MushroomWig

lol midi-chlorians

Come on. They CAN'T be compared. Completely different universes with completely different formats for storytelling. They both have things that are absolutely amazing about them, and they both have aspects that absolutely suck about both of them.

MystikFollower

[QUOTE="MushroomWig"][QUOTE="MetroidPrimePwn"]

Star Trek wins because Star Wars doesn't have "Nuclear wessels".

Theokhoth

lol midi-chlorians

[QUOTE="MystikFollower"]

Come on. They CAN'T be compared. Completely different universes with completely different formats for storytelling. They both have things that are absolutely amazing about them, and they both have aspects that absolutely suck about both of them.

Diablo-B

Not really..... Besides the titles I guess and the massive fanbases around both I don't see much similarity between them. Star Wars has the force, Jedi, sword battles, creepy guys in cloaks. Star trek has Enterprise, phasers, transporters, and dorky uniforms. And I can't think of any Star Trek story that is similar to a Star Wars story. So no, you can't really compare them.

B..b..but it has the force!MushroomWig

lol midi-chlorians

I would have to say that based on movies of both series.. I would say by far Star Trek.. To me even in the older ones there were some lines or some scenes (especially with the new triology) that made me want to facepalm my self.. Oh no he killed younglings! When i heard that said numerous times, I wanted to strangle my self.. Then episode 2 was full of angsty gumpy Anakin in akward teen romance.. The first one, ironically enough Anakin was the worse part of it.. No it wasn't Jar Jar Binx imo, he was meant to be a goofy character.. It was little Anakin again, half the stuff he said wanted me ot strangle my self (are we seeing a pattern?) as well as some of the scenes.. Especially the part where he accidentally blows up a space ship.. sSubZerOo

Yeah the new trilogy was pretty cringe inducing, especially in any lengthy dialogue sequence involving just about anyone. I think the main problem stemmed from the use of TOO much cgi. I would probably consider it harder to act with out an actual set, or real characters in front of you for that matter. Plus, having Haden as Anakin.....ugghhh.

Star Trek >>> Star wars

[QUOTE="sSubZerOo"] I would have to say that based on movies of both series.. I would say by far Star Trek.. To me even in the older ones there were some lines or some scenes (especially with the new triology) that made me want to facepalm my self.. Oh no he killed younglings! When i heard that said numerous times, I wanted to strangle my self.. Then episode 2 was full of angsty gumpy Anakin in akward teen romance.. The first one, ironically enough Anakin was the worse part of it.. No it wasn't Jar Jar Binx imo, he was meant to be a goofy character.. It was little Anakin again, half the stuff he said wanted me ot strangle my self (are we seeing a pattern?) as well as some of the scenes.. Especially the part where he accidentally blows up a space ship.. HoolaHoopMan

Yeah the new trilogy was pretty cringe inducing, especially in any lengthy dialogue sequence involving just about anyone. I think the main problem stemmed from the use of TOO much cgi. I would probably consider it harder to act with out an actual set, or real characters in front of you for that matter. Plus, having Haden as Anakin.....ugghhh.

[QUOTE="HoolaHoopMan"]

[QUOTE="sSubZerOo"] I would have to say that based on movies of both series.. I would say by far Star Trek.. To me even in the older ones there were some lines or some scenes (especially with the new triology) that made me want to facepalm my self.. Oh no he killed younglings! When i heard that said numerous times, I wanted to strangle my self.. Then episode 2 was full of angsty gumpy Anakin in akward teen romance.. The first one, ironically enough Anakin was the worse part of it.. No it wasn't Jar Jar Binx imo, he was meant to be a goofy character.. It was little Anakin again, half the stuff he said wanted me ot strangle my self (are we seeing a pattern?) as well as some of the scenes.. Especially the part where he accidentally blows up a space ship.. sSubZerOo

Yeah the new trilogy was pretty cringe inducing, especially in any lengthy dialogue sequence involving just about anyone. I think the main problem stemmed from the use of TOO much cgi. I would probably consider it harder to act with out an actual set, or real characters in front of you for that matter. Plus, having Haden as Anakin.....ugghhh.

[QUOTE="Diablo-B"][QUOTE="MystikFollower"]

Come on. They CAN'T be compared. Completely different universes with completely different formats for storytelling. They both have things that are absolutely amazing about them, and they both have aspects that absolutely suck about both of them.

Not really..... Besides the titles I guess and the massive fanbases around both I don't see much similarity between them. Star Wars has the force, Jedi, sword battles, creepy guys in cloaks. Star trek has Enterprise, phasers, transporters, and dorky uniforms. And I can't think of any Star Trek story that is similar to a Star Wars story. So no, you can't really compare them.

[QUOTE="HoolaHoopMan"][QUOTE="Theokhoth"]

lol midi-chlorians

sSubZerOo

Yeah, episode two was horrible, but I still like starwars better.

StarTrek. I like StarWars but not as much as StarTrek.

I have to say, I was never that into Star Wars. Star Trek though was always on TV it seemed, and every episode kept me completely entertained.

I have to say, I was never that into Star Wars. Star Trek though was always on TV it seemed, and every episode kept me completely entertained.

Atmanix

[QUOTE="Atmanix"]

I have to say, I was never that into Star Wars. Star Trek though was always on TV it seemed, and every episode kept me completely entertained.

supergamer514

There isn't enough variety. If they did a Star Wars series that would make sense. I'm surprised they haven't actually...

Star Trek easily, the 60s series is awesome.

[QUOTE="supergamer514"][QUOTE="Atmanix"]

I have to say, I was never that into Star Wars. Star Trek though was always on TV it seemed, and every episode kept me completely entertained.

There isn't enough variety. If they did a Star Wars series that would make sense. I'm surprised they haven't actually...

I was never into either, I've honestly never even watched a Star Wars film the whole way through. I never saw any Star Trek stuff before the 2009 remake either, but regardless, I loved that film. So I'll have to go with Star Trek

Trek Wars.KrunkMastaX

EDIT: Oh, you meant you like both of them. Okay, lol.

[QUOTE="Atmanix"]

[QUOTE="supergamer514"] They should have starwars on the Sci-Fi channel. They show star trek way to much! :xsupergamer514

There isn't enough variety. If they did a Star Wars series that would make sense. I'm surprised they haven't actually...

I don't have cable :(

Star Wars, I never had the chance to like Star Trek and I find the different species very weird. I know I'm a bit hypocritical when you think of Chewbacca, but I find Star Trek very strange, and the enemies are never as cool as Darth Maul.

For me, it's Star Trek, although I don't think the two should really be compared like this as they are very different.

[QUOTE="supergamer514"][QUOTE="Atmanix"]

There isn't enough variety. If they did a Star Wars series that would make sense. I'm surprised they haven't actually...

I don't have cable :(