http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XY7li8Lb1eg Katana vs machine gun, make a prediction on what happens, and tell me if you guessed it right. I know i didnt. Go to 4:20 to see it happen
This topic is locked from further discussion.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XY7li8Lb1eg Katana vs machine gun, make a prediction on what happens, and tell me if you guessed it right. I know i didnt. Go to 4:20 to see it happen
In the beginning of the video the katana splits pistol bullets in half. so i thought the machine gun would be no diffrenthow is that a suprise unless you get your ballistics data from anime?
Riverwolf007
[QUOTE="Riverwolf007"]In the beginning of the video the katana splits pistol bullets in half. so i thought the machine gun would be no diffrenthow is that a suprise unless you get your ballistics data from anime?
FPSunionOWNS
.... A soft pistol bullet does not equate to a full metal jacket 50 caliber machine gun going atat like 1500 to 2500 meters per second..
......What a surprise.. A large calibre machine gun designed to go through modern day armor plating can break a small sword!sSubZerOoWatch the super slow video and the katana cuts several bullets before breaking
[QUOTE="sSubZerOo"]......What a surprise.. A large calibre machine gun designed to go through modern day armor plating can break a small sword!markop2003Watch the super slow video and the katana cuts several bullets before breaking
Yeah and?
In the beginning of the video the katana splits pistol bullets in half. so i thought the machine gun would be no diffrent[QUOTE="FPSunionOWNS"][QUOTE="Riverwolf007"]
how is that a suprise unless you get your ballistics data from anime?
sSubZerOo
.... A soft pistol bullet does not equate to a full metal jacket 50 caliber machine gun going atat like 1500 to 2500 meters per second..
that's pretty bonking fast. sure you aren't mixing m/s with fps? m/s would be around 900
I'm not sure what this is trying to prove. Even if one slices a bullet, wouldn't the fragments still have sufficient force to kill the sword wielder?
[QUOTE="sSubZerOo"]
[QUOTE="FPSunionOWNS"] In the beginning of the video the katana splits pistol bullets in half. so i thought the machine gun would be no diffrentFirebird-5
.... A soft pistol bullet does not equate to a full metal jacket 50 caliber machine gun going atat like 1500 to 2500 meters per second..
that's pretty bonking fast. sure you aren't mixing m/s with fps? m/s would be around 900
apoligies I meant FEET.
i dont think its trying to prove anything, just a fun experiment that people can try and predict the outcome. Although everyone here did not make predictions they just watched it and commented on how dumb i am for thinking the sword would prevail.I'm not sure what this is trying to prove. Even if you slice a bullet, wouldn't the fragments still have sufficient force to kill the sword wielder?
uhoh_hotdogs
I'm not sure what this is trying to prove. Even if one slices a bullet, wouldn't the fragments still have sufficient force to kill the sword wielder?
uhoh_hotdogs
Who would be able to hit a bullet witha katana in the first place?
[QUOTE="sSubZerOo"]......What a surprise.. A large calibre machine gun designed to go through modern day armor plating can break a small sword!markop2003Watch the super slow video and the katana cuts several bullets before breakingSeems like that would happen when you are shooting the sharp, thin end of the sword. If they put the sword sideways I'm sure the bullets would have mowed it down much quicker.
[QUOTE="uhoh_hotdogs"]
I'm not sure what this is trying to prove. Even if one slices a bullet, wouldn't the fragments still have sufficient force to kill the sword wielder?
ROFLCOPTER603
Who would be able to hit a bullet witha katana in the first place?
:x I don't have common sense.
[QUOTE="uhoh_hotdogs"]
I'm not sure what this is trying to prove. Even if one slices a bullet, wouldn't the fragments still have sufficient force to kill the sword wielder?
ROFLCOPTER603
Who would be able to hit a bullet witha katana in the first place?
This guy probably.
[QUOTE="ROFLCOPTER603"]
[QUOTE="uhoh_hotdogs"]
I'm not sure what this is trying to prove. Even if one slices a bullet, wouldn't the fragments still have sufficient force to kill the sword wielder?
KamuiFei
Who would be able to hit a bullet witha katana in the first place?
This guy probably.
That's amazing.
[QUOTE="markop2003"][QUOTE="sSubZerOo"]......What a surprise.. A large calibre machine gun designed to go through modern day armor plating can break a small sword!BMD004Watch the super slow video and the katana cuts several bullets before breakingSeems like that would happen when you are shooting the sharp, thin end of the sword. If they put the sword sideways I'm sure the bullets would have mowed it down much quicker.
Exactly. A big .50 calibre (lead) bullet hitting the very thin, sharp (metal) edge of a sword? Of course the bullet is going to shatter. I don't see what was so amazing.
Post of the thread. :lol:That was awkwardly symbolic of Japan's transition from feudalism to industrialism.
PatchMaster
Hahah this is a hilarious clip. They just love to make it dramatic. I love how they show the slow-mo sword cutting several of the bullets together with some grand jrpg boss battle music (it's actually a good song) and then finish the video of with some sad melody. If you'd just listen to the video it sounds more than the last ten minutes of some rpg game rather than an experiment. The lovely dramatic music for these dull and trivial scenes just makes me laugh out loud.
.50 BMG rounds vs. Katana....yup, didn't need to even finish that to know what would happen. The Germans and Japanese learned to fear the Mah Deuce because their armored halftracks and even light tanks would be turned into swiss cheese by the round, and those had around 1-2" of armor.
The result: Both the katana and the .50 cal won. The katana split a few bullets before meeting its demise due to being overwhelmed. It would be like a single, master samurai taking on 100 men at once. He would get some, but would fall to being outnumbered. . . I like how at the end they had the sad, dramatic war music playing in the background as they showed the sword winning and then breaking in slo-mo. It reminded me of the music and scene in Platoon when Willem Dafoe was getting shot by a million rounds but still had enough to reach up towards the helicopter before dying.
Fake. Bullets can be deflected quite easily with a sword.SolidSnake35match for a sword, blaster is not
At first I thought the machine gun would win, but when you said I wouldn't be right, I switched to the katana.
Well played.
Fake. Bullets can be deflected quite easily with a sword.SolidSnake35You watch too much television. What happened was exactly what I thought would happen, katanas break easily, what makes katanas special is their sharpness, and those bullets could cut through cars.
[QUOTE="Riverwolf007"]In the beginning of the video the katana splits pistol bullets in half. so i thought the machine gun would be no diffrent brother, its a 50 cal. If a bullet wizzes right next to your head with that thing, you would die.how is that a suprise unless you get your ballistics data from anime?
FPSunionOWNS
[QUOTE="Riverwolf007"]In the beginning of the video the katana splits pistol bullets in half. so i thought the machine gun would be no diffrent 9mm pistol bullets are airsoft pellets compared to the rounds fired by a machine gun like that.how is that a suprise unless you get your ballistics data from anime?
FPSunionOWNS
Watch the super slow video and the katana cuts several bullets before breaking[QUOTE="markop2003"][QUOTE="sSubZerOo"]......What a surprise.. A large calibre machine gun designed to go through modern day armor plating can break a small sword!sSubZerOo
Yeah and?
The bullets were shattering from the impact more than anything, and every bullet that struck it took out a pretty big chunk. Its not because of the sharpness its because it's hitting the blade and glancing off because it wasn't a dead center shot.Katana loses to table. What makes you think it can beat mg?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntXkuqZ2Fo4
Domobomb
Thats a cheaply made, probably "rat-tail" tang stainless steel garbage katana. The one against the machine gun was a masterfully crafted authentic weapon. No comparison.
Edited to add: And the guy handling it was an idiot for not treating a weapon with respect.
[QUOTE="Domobomb"]
Katana loses to table. What makes you think it can beat mg?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntXkuqZ2Fo4
KamuiFei
Thats a cheaply made, probably "rat-tail" tang stainless steel garbage katana. The one against the machine gun was a masterfully crafted authentic weapon. No comparison.
Yeah, I'm sure he knows that, but it's still hilarious. :lol:
[QUOTE="KamuiFei"]
[QUOTE="Domobomb"]
Katana loses to table. What makes you think it can beat mg?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntXkuqZ2Fo4
howlrunner13
Thats a cheaply made, probably "rat-tail" tang stainless steel garbage katana. The one against the machine gun was a masterfully crafted authentic weapon. No comparison.
Yeah, I'm sure he knows that, but it's still hilarious. :lol:
Haha, yea, the guy was an idiot for banging it on that table. :lol:
[QUOTE="SolidSnake35"]Fake. Bullets can be deflected quite easily with a sword.Mr_AlexanderYou watch too much television. What happened was exactly what I thought would happen, katanas break easily, what makes katanas special is their sharpness, and those bullets could cut through cars. Tv? Try first hand experience.
[QUOTE="Mr_Alexander"][QUOTE="SolidSnake35"]Fake. Bullets can be deflected quite easily with a sword.SolidSnake35You watch too much television. What happened was exactly what I thought would happen, katanas break easily, what makes katanas special is their sharpness, and those bullets could cut through cars. Tv? Try first hand experience.
dont bring a knife to a gun fight?
I'm not suprised. People, anime is not a historical representation ofweapons. Japanese weapons have no special powers, M'kay.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment