which is the best metallica album?

I love '.. and justice for all' the most

Anyone who says Black Album needs to listen to more Metallica

Ride the Lightning.

1) Master of Puppets

2) Ride the Lightning

3) Kill em' All (Metal Up Your *^*)

4) ...and Justice for All

The rest suck.

In my opinion:

1) Kill 'Em All(Metal Up Your Ass) and Ride the Lightning tied

3) Master of Puppets

4) ...And Justice For All

5) Black Album

6) S&M Album

7) Garage Inc.

8 ) Load

9) Re-Load

10) St. Anger

Coming from a huge Metallica fan. :D

In my opinion:

1) Kill 'Em All and Ride the Lightning tied

3) Master of Puppets

4) ...And Justice For All

5) Black Album

6) S&M Album

7) Garage Inc.

8) Load

9) Re-Load

10) St. Anger

Coming from a huge Metallica fan. :D

TM_Darkside

Lol basically chronalogical order :P

Not saying I disagree...

But let's hope Death Magnetic bucks the trend.

my favorite is load. its really different from their other albums, but i like listening to it.Xeros606

[QUOTE="Xeros606"]my favorite is load. its really different from their other albums, but i like listening to it.suicidalpoptrt

I was wondering if anyone would quote that. Anyway, it's good that someone loves Load.

[QUOTE="suicidalpoptrt"][QUOTE="Xeros606"]my favorite is load. its really different from their other albums, but i like listening to it.TM_Darkside

I was wondering if anyone would quote that. Anyway, it's good that someone loves Load.

[QUOTE="TM_Darkside"]

[QUOTE="suicidalpoptrt"][QUOTE="Xeros606"]my favorite is load. its really different from their other albums, but i like listening to it.darksword1123

I was wondering if anyone would quote that. Anyway, it's good that someone loves Load.

Epic fail

Load at least had King Nothing, 2x4, and Hero of the Day.

[QUOTE="suicidalpoptrt"][QUOTE="Xeros606"]my favorite is load. its really different from their other albums, but i like listening to it.TM_Darkside

I was wondering if anyone would quote that. Anyway, it's good that someone loves Load.

I like Load

Just nowhere near as much as Ride the Lightning.

[QUOTE="darksword1123"][QUOTE="TM_Darkside"]

[QUOTE="suicidalpoptrt"][QUOTE="Xeros606"]my favorite is load. its really different from their other albums, but i like listening to it.Juggernaut140

I was wondering if anyone would quote that. Anyway, it's good that someone loves Load.

Epic fail

Load at least had King Nothing, 2x4, and Hero of the Day.

I love '.. and justice for all' the most

Lukanot

I love '.. and justice for all' the most

Lukanot

Me too i just love ...And Justice For All

i like st. anger. :)

But then i like all their albums. :)

Alright then. How was ST. Anger better? Terrible drumming, vocals and NO SOLO'S and not a single good song on the album. Load is only hated because it sounds different than other Metallica albums.Juggernaut140

[QUOTE="Juggernaut140"]Alright then. How was ST. Anger better? Terrible drumming, vocals and NO SOLO'S and not a single good song on the album. Load is only hated because it sounds different than other Metallica albums.darksword1123

I wonder why they would need to attempt to reach a more mainstream audience. The Black Album was incredibly succesful.

[QUOTE="Juggernaut140"]Alright then. How was ST. Anger better? Terrible drumming, vocals and NO SOLO'S and not a single good song on the album. Load is only hated because it sounds different than other Metallica albums.darksword1123

The Black Album was their first sell out. Then, years later they try to re-sell out with something called St. Anger that they foolishly thought would appeal to the current mass market a decade after the last time they sold out, except this time it was truly a joke of a marketing error, and no one thought it was cool or even funny the second time around.

[QUOTE="darksword1123"][QUOTE="Juggernaut140"]Alright then. How was ST. Anger better? Terrible drumming, vocals and NO SOLO'S and not a single good song on the album. Load is only hated because it sounds different than other Metallica albums.ConfessiBear

The Black Album was their first sell out. Then, years later they try to re-sell out with something called St. Anger that they foolishly thought would appeal to the current mass market a decade after the last time they sold out, except this time it was truly a joke of a marketing error, and no one thought it was cool or even funny the second time around.

And it'll happen again with their next album.

ride the lightning

[QUOTE="ConfessiBear"]

[QUOTE="darksword1123"][QUOTE="Juggernaut140"]Alright then. How was ST. Anger better? Terrible drumming, vocals and NO SOLO'S and not a single good song on the album. Load is only hated because it sounds different than other Metallica albums.pinneyapple

The Black Album was their first sell out. Then, years later they try to re-sell out with something called St. Anger that they foolishly thought would appeal to the current mass market a decade after the last time they sold out, except this time it was truly a joke of a marketing error, and no one thought it was cool or even funny the second time around.

And it'll happen again with their next album.

justiceMetallicaKings

Master of Puppets

ride the lighting was the best

Ordered from best to worst IMO:

1. Kill 'Em All
2. Ride The Lightning
3. Master of Puppets
4. ...And Justice For All
5. "Metallica" (Black Album)
6. ReLoad
7. Load
8. St. Anger

[QUOTE="pinneyapple"][QUOTE="ConfessiBear"]

[QUOTE="darksword1123"][QUOTE="Juggernaut140"]Alright then. How was ST. Anger better? Terrible drumming, vocals and NO SOLO'S and not a single good song on the album. Load is only hated because it sounds different than other Metallica albums.darksword1123

The Black Album was their first sell out. Then, years later they try to re-sell out with something called St. Anger that they foolishly thought would appeal to the current mass market a decade after the last time they sold out, except this time it was truly a joke of a marketing error, and no one thought it was cool or even funny the second time around.

And it'll happen again with their next album.

Give it a chance. They might finally surprise us. :)