You like rap??

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

Rikusaki

I think you're getting confused about vocal melody.

Is a drum solo not music?

Rap = music.

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

Rikusaki

What is rap then?

oh please!

quit being so damn stubborn and close minded

that is great music right there
kidcool189

Not to me.

[QUOTE="kidcool189"][QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

Rikusaki

if u want, i'll even post more...

That just sounds like more Rap. Not music.

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

bradleybhoy

I think you're getting confused about vocal melody.

Is a drum solo not music?

Rap = music.

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

-Austin-

What is rap then?

IMO, Rap isn't music.

A drum solo is music as much as a guitar solo is.

It's not the pitch of the sound itself. It's also how you combine different kinds of sounds to make a melody.

Rap doesn't have that.

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

Rikusaki

I think you're getting confused about vocal melody.

Is a drum solo not music?

Rap = music.

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

-Austin-

What is rap then?

IMO, Rap isn't music.

A drum solo is music as much as a guitar solo is.

It's not the pitch of the sound itself. It's also how you combine different kinds of sounds to make a melody.

Rap doesn't have that.

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

Rikusaki

I think you're getting confused about vocal melody.

Is a drum solo not music?

Rap = music.

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

-Austin-

What is rap then?

IMO, Rap isn't music.

A drum solo is music as much as a guitar solo is.

It's not the pitch of the sound itself. It's also how you combine different kinds of sounds to make a melody.

Rap doesn't have that.

If a melody is a combination of different sounds, than hip hop has a melody.

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

Rikusaki

I think you're getting confused about vocal melody.

Is a drum solo not music?

Rap = music.

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

Rap lacks a melody.

It clealy states within the definition of music that a melody is required for it to qualify as music.

You can't deny it.

ITS FACT.

-Austin-

What is rap then?

IMO, Rap isn't music.

A drum solo is music as much as a guitar solo is.

It's not the pitch of the sound itself. It's also how you combine different kinds of sounds to make a melody.

Rap doesn't have that.

I thought this was a matter of fact.

rap = music

regardless of anyone's opinion

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

[QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

bradleybhoy

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(barcx17

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(barcx17

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

-Austin-

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

[QUOTE="barcx17"]As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(airg6

Practicing guitar solos 12 hours a day in your bedroom doesn't make you talented.

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

It's not an opinion. It's a fact that hip hop is a form of music.

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

-Austin-

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

How?

I can't believe that we have come to this.

Actually thinking that this is really good music.

We need to apriciate the geniuses that actually write MUSIC.

MUSIC that fits the definiton of MUSIC....

Nobuo Uematsu

Yoko Shimomura

Hans Zimmer

John Williams

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

bradleybhoy

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

[QUOTE="barcx17"]As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(airg6

never heard of those guitar players, sorry.

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

-Austin-

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

It's not an opinion. It's a fact that hip hop is a form of music.

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

good for you

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

It's not an opinion. It's a fact that hip hop is a form of music.

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, as much as you like to assume that they really wanted to play guitar but were too indolent that isn't the case. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

bradleybhoy

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, it wasn't a cheap way out because they really wanted to play guitar but couldn't. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

Obviously producing hip hop is easy....;)

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

Rikusaki

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

How?

I can't believe that we have come to this.

Actually thinking that this is really good music.

We need to apriciate the geniuses that actually write MUSIC.

MUSIC that fits the definiton of MUSIC....

Nobuo Uematsu

Yoko Shimomura

Hans Zimmer

John Williams

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="barcx17"]As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(-Austin-

Practicing guitar solos 12 hours a day in your bedroom doesn't make you talented.

[QUOTE="-Austin-"]

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="barcx17"]As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(airg6

Practicing guitar solos 12 hours a day in your bedroom doesn't make you talented.

Petrucci wanks. Seriously, good for you, you can play a bagillion notes a minute. You music isn't compelling at all and the lyrics don't mean anything on a personal level, the way good MCs do.

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

-Austin-

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, it wasn't a cheap way out because they really wanted to play guitar but couldn't. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

Obviously producing hip hop is easy....;)

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

Rikusaki

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

But it's still music....

How?

I can't believe that we have come to this.

Actually thinking that this is really good music.

We need to apriciate the geniuses that actually write MUSIC.

MUSIC that fits the definiton of MUSIC....

Nobuo Uematsu

Yoko Shimomura

Hans Zimmer

John Williams

Appreciation of Hip-Hop and other music is not exclusive.

But if you'd rather take the snob approach and pretend Hip-Hop isn't music to puff up your own supposedly supreme musical taste then be my guest.

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"]

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="barcx17"]As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(-Austin-

Practicing guitar solos 12 hours a day in your bedroom doesn't make you talented.

Petrucci wanks. Seriously, good for you, you can play a bagillion notes a minute. You music isn't compelling at all and the lyrics don't mean anything on a personal level, the way good MCs do.

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, it wasn't a cheap way out because they really wanted to play guitar but couldn't. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

Obviously producing hip hop is easy....;)

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

iHeartCali

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, it wasn't a cheap way out because they really wanted to play guitar but couldn't. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

Obviously producing hip hop is easy....;)

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, it wasn't a cheap way out because they really wanted to play guitar but couldn't. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

Obviously producing hip hop is easy....;)

"Make a beat" entails a lot if you're trying to better Hip-Hop's greatest producers.

[QUOTE="iHeartCali"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

airg6

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, it wasn't a cheap way out because they really wanted to play guitar but couldn't. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

Obviously producing hip hop is easy....;)

What do nursery rhymes have to do with hip hop?

What? Are you getting mad because I just proved my point?airg6

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="iHeartCali"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="airg6"]

In my oppinion, I don think rap should be called music but instead a poetic art form which it is.

-Austin-

Except that there is this thing called "music" which MCs tend to rap over.

Bad is your opinion. And not all Hip-Hop music is "computer generated", in fact my favourite Hip-Hop producers sample. And you'll find repetition is an integral part of a lot of modern music.

Hip-Hop producers aren't musicians who couldn't make it. They didn't try to learn an instrument and then give up and take up producing. Love for Hip-Hop and even necessity made the best like Pete Rock and DJ Premier become prodcuers, it wasn't a cheap way out because they really wanted to play guitar but couldn't. And do you know how knowledgable of recorded music you have to be to sample originally and creatively? I suppose not.

Obviously producing hip hop is easy....;)

What do nursery rhymes have to do with hip hop?

[QUOTE="airg6"]What? Are you getting mad because I just proved my point?iHeartCali

[QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"]

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="barcx17"]As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(airg6

Practicing guitar solos 12 hours a day in your bedroom doesn't make you talented.

Petrucci wanks. Seriously, good for you, you can play a bagillion notes a minute. You music isn't compelling at all and the lyrics don't mean anything on a personal level, the way good MCs do.

I find nothing epic about them

[QUOTE="iHeartCali"][QUOTE="airg6"]What? Are you getting mad because I just proved my point?airg6

What is your point?

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"][QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="-Austin-"]

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="barcx17"]As much as you guys are trying, just give up. These people will just never accept rap as music... shame really :(barcx17

Practicing guitar solos 12 hours a day in your bedroom doesn't make you talented.

Petrucci wanks. Seriously, good for you, you can play a bagillion notes a minute. You music isn't compelling at all and the lyrics don't mean anything on a personal level, the way good MCs do.

I find nothing epic about them

[QUOTE="iHeartCali"][QUOTE="airg6"]What? Are you getting mad because I just proved my point?airg6

[QUOTE="airg6"][QUOTE="iHeartCali"][QUOTE="airg6"]What? Are you getting mad because I just proved my point?bradleybhoy

What is your point?