I have a friend that told me if you buy games used, then the company that made them won't get any of the profit. I wanted to correct him because that sounds wrong, but to be honest I have no clue. Is this true?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Go ahead and buy used games.
Don't worry about the all the crying from developers and publishers, they made their profits when they sold the game the first time, just like Chevy and the car dealership did when I purchased my vehicle.
If Chevy and the dealer were silly enough to suggest that they wanted a piece of the pie when I sell my vehicle to someone else, I would laugh in their face. Sadly, devs and publishers are beyond retarded/greedy, so we have had to listen to them cry poverty because of "lost revenue" due to used game sales for the last few years.
I'm looking forward to the day that they realize how ridiculous their argument is, and then put it to rest once and for all.
Same as on PC, with almost no problems of getting a fully functional product (unlike on PC), but it's being "fixed", they're slowly moving towards things like PC, account bound games or features (multiplayer, content, etc).Yeah I should have posted this in the ps3 section. It mostly had to do with buying a used ps3 game for gamestop, sorry for the confusion.
lolrawrz
Dude, what?
There isn't really a used games market on PC, so this is the wrong section for one thing.
For another, if you sold somebody your car, then they sold it to somebody else, would you get any of the money they got from when they sold it? I mean, its kind of obvious that the money won't be going back to the creators, especially considering the bajillions of games that have online passes and day one free DLC to deter used game purchases.
Wrong forum, used games are almost (if not) dead on PC gaming. But, is it wrong to buy used games?; no, it isn't. Go ahead and do it. The developer/publisher already got the money. When they say that selling used games is worse than pirating a game ignore them, it is just bla bla bla because they are too greedy and want more money. Miroku32
Yeah, the publishers and developers don't get money from used game sales, but that's because they already got the money when it was new. I don't understand the fuss, movies, books and music have no such compunction, while digital sales (which make up a hefty portion of income for creators) means they don't have to worry about it. I bought the game and gave them my money, its my right to sell it since I own it.
But no, they don't get a dime if I do sell it.
to the company there is no difference between pirating and used which makes me sad since i want to give namco all my $$$JigglyWiggly_
pirating and used games are waayy different....but i guess you knwo that and just trying to troll....
[QUOTE="JigglyWiggly_"]to the company there is no difference between pirating and used which makes me sad since i want to give namco all my $$$undeadgoon
pirating and used games are waayy different....but i guess you knwo that and just trying to troll....
For companies, they are identical, but considering your post in that other thread, I wouldn't be surprised if you actually believed they aren't.[QUOTE="undeadgoon"][QUOTE="JigglyWiggly_"]to the company there is no difference between pirating and used which makes me sad since i want to give namco all my $$$DanielDust
pirating and used games are waayy different....but i guess you knwo that and just trying to troll....
For companies, they are identical, but considering your post in that other thread, I wouldn't be surprised if you actually believed they aren't.Not at all, for a game to be used it has to be bought first... company gets money.. and is one copy....
Pirating ... the company doesnt get anything at all.. and can be many copies that isnt being paid for...
For companies, they are identical, but considering your post in that other thread, I wouldn't be surprised if you actually believed they aren't.[QUOTE="DanielDust"][QUOTE="undeadgoon"]
pirating and used games are waayy different....but i guess you knwo that and just trying to troll....
undeadgoon
Not at all, for a game to be used it has to be bought first... company gets money.. and is one copy....
Pirating ... the company doesnt get anything at all.. and can be many copies that isnt being paid for...
Pirating - company doesn't get money. Resale - company doesn't get money. Yes, it's that simple, take it as you logic, pirated copies also come from legit copies of games.[QUOTE="undeadgoon"][QUOTE="DanielDust"] For companies, they are identical, but considering your post in that other thread, I wouldn't be surprised if you actually believed they aren't.DanielDust
Not at all, for a game to be used it has to be bought first... company gets money.. and is one copy....
Pirating ... the company doesnt get anything at all.. and can be many copies that isnt being paid for...
Pirating - company doesn't get money. Resale - company doesn't get money. Yes, it's that simple, take it as you logic, pirated copies also come from legit copies of games.Used games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one?Used games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Captain__Tripps
[QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"]Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one? depends on the game... and how well it soldUsed games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Miroku32
The real issue here is that very few games are worth $60 these days, but gamers still like to be able to play those games at a reduced price.
If developers start making games that people feel are worth $60, people will glady pay the money (just look at day one sales of Call of Duty every November).
Until you do that, don't expect people to shell out $60 for a game that should be priced at $20 from the start.
[QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"]Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one? $20 is still money paid the publisher/dev doesn't see. So its still worse in that it was a "real" lost sale, verses a true pirate who never pays for anything... Maybe the industry should get in the used game business. Car companys have... lolUsed games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Miroku32
[QUOTE="Miroku32"][QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"]Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one? $20 is still money paid the publisher/dev doesn't see. So its still worse in that it was a "real" lost sale, verses a true pirate who never pays for anything... Maybe the industry should get in the used game business. Car companys have... lolUsed games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Captain__Tripps
The gaming industry has you brainwashed into thinking that the developers deserve to continue making money off their game after it's purchased initially. Can't think of any other industry that has pulled this **** on the consumer. Once it's bought retail, it's none of their god damn business what happens to the game...they made the money they're entitled to.
Maybe if they sold games cheaper, people would be less inclined to purchase them used. Sorry, but taking a risk on a $60 game is a bit much to ask of the average gamer considering how **** terrible the games are these days.
$20 is still money paid the publisher/dev doesn't see. So its still worse in that it was a "real" lost sale, verses a true pirate who never pays for anything... Maybe the industry should get in the used game business. Car companys have... lol[QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"][QUOTE="Miroku32"] Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one?xxxLUGZxxx
The gaming industry has you brainwashed into thinking that the developers deserve to continue making money off their game after it's purchased initially. Can't think of any other industry that has pulled this **** on the consumer. Once it's bought retail, it's none of their god damn business what happens to the game...they made the money they're entitled to.
Maybe if they sold games cheaper, people would be less inclined to purchase them used. Sorry, but taking a risk on a $60 game is a bit much to ask of the average gamer considering how **** terrible the games are these days.
Im not saying they deserve the money twice, I am saying that from their perspective, you could argue that used games are worse than piracy because in the case of used games they are willing to pay money, sometimes almost as much as new release price.[QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"]Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one? The real truth is, I can't tell you to buy it new, even though I would love more than anything to lecture you on the subject. I think if you can't buy it new at that price, man up, and buy it when it goes on sale. At least then, the developer will get something, and you'll be able to get your game and contribute. Otherwise, buying it completely used, means the developer gets nothing. You get to eat your cake, but everyone else is watching. I don't need to explain it any further than that.Used games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Miroku32
$20 is still money paid the publisher/dev doesn't see. So its still worse in that it was a "real" lost sale, verses a true pirate who never pays for anything... Maybe the industry should get in the used game business. Car companys have... lol[QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"][QUOTE="Miroku32"] Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one?xxxLUGZxxx
The gaming industry has you brainwashed into thinking that the developers deserve to continue making money off their game after it's purchased initially. Can't think of any other industry that has pulled this **** on the consumer. Once it's bought retail, it's none of their god damn business what happens to the game...they made the money they're entitled to.
Maybe if they sold games cheaper, people would be less inclined to purchase them used. Sorry, but taking a risk on a $60 game is a bit much to ask of the average gamer considering how **** terrible the games are these days.
The developer isn't getting the money twice.. Where do you guys get this thinking from? Used game sales is like buying one copy and letting the whole neighborhood borrow it. The developer sees none of the money they should be earning. No one said you had to take a risk on a $60 game. No one is holding a gun to your head to make you buy it. If you buy a terrible game, the only person at fault is YOU, and only you. Isn't it free will? But it's easy for crybabies to put the blame on someone else.Why buying 2nd hand games when you have steam sales? Even in the early 00s i refused to get used games, can't stand touching a sticky box with fat choco finger prints all around.
Used game selling is or was just a business by game stores for getting little profit from shabby customers.
[QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"]Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one? Buying used "products" is one thing, buying licenses/access to personal services from another person that contracted the services is not the same (do you sell your internet connection to theneighborhood?).Used games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Miroku32
Used games are worse than piracy, because they're not only making money multiples times on one single copy of a game (used games for companies like Gamestop are like renting, they always lure people back for "great" deals for their games), illegal money that is passed off as legal, sooner or later all console games will become similar to PC games because of that.
The developer isn't getting the money twice.. Where do you guys get this thinking from? Used game sales is like buying one copy and letting the whole neighborhood borrow it. The developer sees none of the money they should be earning. No one said you had to take a risk on a $60 game. No one is holding a gun to your head to make you buy it. If you buy a terrible game, the only person at fault is YOU, and only you. Isn't it free will? But it's easy for crybabies to put the blame on someone else.Elann2008He didn't say that the developers get the money twice, he is saying that the developers convinced you and many other people that they should deserve the money that comes from every sale the game, regardless if you buy it new or used.
Personally, I'm also surprised how this is the only industry that hates the purchase of used products. Never thought I would see when that happened.
[QUOTE="Miroku32"][QUOTE="Captain__Tripps"]Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one? The real truth is, I can't tell you to buy it new, even though I would love more than anything to lecture you on the subject. I think if you can't buy it new at that price, man up, and buy it when it goes on sale. At least then, the developer will get something, and you'll be able to get your game and contribute. Otherwise, buying it completely used, means the developer gets nothing. You get to eat your cake, but everyone else is watching. I don't need to explain it any further than that.Um wow. If there's a good deal on used games for console, I take advantage of it as long as there's no multiplayer pass on the game. Why would you purposely pay more money for something? It's the game maker's fault for not implementing something that makes you buy new.Used games are argubley worse. If someone buys a used copy at gamestop for $55, that is real money that the publisher would have seen, that they dont for a savings of 5 bucks... a cheap pirate, likely would have not bought it used or new, but the used buyer would be more likely to buy a new copy if there was no used one available...
Elann2008
What it comes down to for me is I'm allowed to sell anything else I want used. I don't see any reason games should be any different. It's my right as a consumer of a physical product. (A disk, a digital copy is a completely seperate issue.)
I think the reason developers/publishers complain about it is because the current gaming market is unsustainable. So much money is spent on development and advertising that they have to make up for, so instead of cutting costs they decide to fight used game sales. I don't understand why development costs are rising so much. What is it that requires that much extra work to make it cost so much more than it used to? It can't be graphics alone. What else has changed?
If you sell your car than Ford or Toyota don't get any profit from that either. Why is this only an issue with software and not any other kind of mechandise?
fenriz275
probably because software doesn't show signs of wear
also cars need dat maintenance
dun get me wrong i want used games to continue to be sold.
Pretty much every single other software product isn't allowed to be sold used.What it comes down to for me is I'm allowed to sell anything else I want used. I don't see any reason games should be any different. It's my right as a consumer of a physical product. (A disk, a digital copy is a completely seperate issue.)
I think the reason developers/publishers complain about it is because the current gaming market is unsustainable. So much money is spent on development and advertising that they have to make up for, so instead of cutting costs they decide to fight used game sales. I don't understand why development costs are rising so much. What is it that requires that much extra work to make it cost so much more than it used to? It can't be graphics alone. What else has changed?
INF1DEL
[QUOTE="fenriz275"]
If you sell your car than Ford or Toyota don't get any profit from that either. Why is this only an issue with software and not any other kind of mechandise?
JigglyWiggly_
probably because software doesn't show signs of wear
also cars need dat maintenance
dun get me wrong i want used games to continue to be sold.
Neither do DVD movies. Used books are functionally the same as a new one too, although they obviously do degrade. But so does the "package" of a game...[QUOTE="JigglyWiggly_"][QUOTE="fenriz275"]
If you sell your car than Ford or Toyota don't get any profit from that either. Why is this only an issue with software and not any other kind of mechandise?
Captain__Tripps
probably because software doesn't show signs of wear
also cars need dat maintenance
dun get me wrong i want used games to continue to be sold.
Neither do DVD movies. Used books are functionally the same as a new one too, although they obviously do degrade. But so does the "package" of a game...people still watch DVDs?
and used books can be gross, games when I buy used, I submerge the cases in dat water/lysol/alcohoal and clean dem cartridges gud.
unrelated
about dem books
i've bought a book for reading for fun for the first time in my rife last month.
The real truth is, I can't tell you to buy it new, even though I would love more than anything to lecture you on the subject. I think if you can't buy it new at that price, man up, and buy it when it goes on sale. At least then, the developer will get something, and you'll be able to get your game and contribute. Otherwise, buying it completely used, means the developer gets nothing. You get to eat your cake, but everyone else is watching. I don't need to explain it any further than that.Um wow. If there's a good deal on used games for console, I take advantage of it as long as there's no multiplayer pass on the game. Why would you purposely pay more money for something? It's the game maker's fault for not implementing something that makes you buy new. There are always good deals. People lack patience. They want it DAY ONE. If you want it day one, then pay up. If you don't like what you're getting.. then you know what to do right? I think everyone here is a big boy.[QUOTE="Elann2008"][QUOTE="Miroku32"] Come on, then if that's so buying used products is something that should be punishable by law I admit that ppl are stupid in buying a game by $55 in Gamestop while buying it new is $60 but what if the game is like $20 or something like that?; where I live 3DS games cost $50 without taxes and I managed to buy RE:Revelations at $24 used. What would you do?; buy the game at $50 or buy the used one?cain006
if the game isnt available on digital stores or you cant find a hard copy, then i dont see why a person cant buy them used
Like many others in this thread, I'll never understand how game companies ever convinced their customers that the used market is destroying all that is good in this world. Outside of the software industry, there is a used market for every other type of IP. Books? Yep. In fact, a great many college students are able to purchase all the books required because they're able to buy and sell used books. DVDs? Yep. They're not worth a whole lot, but I'm allowed to sell my copy any time I want. Music CDs? Again, I can do as I want.
This needs to extend to all digital products. If I no longer want to play Skyrim on my PC, use Matlab, listen to the mp3 I purchased, etc., I should be allowed to sell it someone else. But somehow, the companies have convinced politicians and judges that I only secured the rights to access the content, not ownership of that particular copy. Hell, I'm actually surprised they haven't found some way to extend that sort of logic to DVDs, CDs, books, and console games.
You can't sell services, that's what games are, especially on PC and soon to be so on consoles (most likely with the new console wave this will be the standard). If you're making such analogies, I see why you're incapable of understanding.Like many others in this thread, I'll never understand how game companies ever convinced their customers that the used market is destroying all that is good in this world. Outside of the software industry, there is a used market for every other type of IP. Books? Yep. In fact, a great many college students are able to purchase all the books required because they're able to buy and sell used books. DVDs? Yep. They're not worth a whole lot, but I'm allowed to sell my copy any time I want. Music CDs? Again, I can do as I want.
This needs to extend to all digital products. If I no longer want to play Skyrim on my PC, use Matlab, listen to the mp3 I purchased, etc., I should be allowed to sell it someone else. But somehow, the companies have convinced politicians and judges that I only secured the rights to access the content, not ownership of that particular copy. Hell, I'm actually surprised they haven't found some way to extend that sort of logic to DVDs, CDs, books, and console games.
megam
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment