Half-Life 2 is still a very modern game and doesn't feel dated at all.
In my opinion, however, I don't think any FPS feels "dated". If you think about it, the core gameplay of the genre really hasn't changed that much over the years: bad guys show up in certain places, you shoot them until they're dead, lather, rinse and repeat. The only elements of the genre that have really evolved over the years are graphics and storytelling (i.e. interactivity). If a game has unforgiving mechanics and sloppy controls, it was probably a mediocre game when it was released too.
Half-Life 1 has amazing gunplay, great weapons, outstanding level design and extremely tight controls (I'm talking about the original here, NOT the shoddy port, Half-Life: Source). It is by all standards an excellent shooter, even today. Whether or not you enjoy it will probably be largely based on how much you enjoy the setting and set pieces, and your tolerance of the graphics, which I would say are rather servicable and don't get in the way of the experience at all.
Personally, I actually think the first game was better. In my book: HL1 > Half-Life 2 > Opposing Force > the rest of the series.
YMMV, but there is absolutely no reason I can think of for anybody not to own these games, especially at today's crazy prices. :)
Log in to comment