Doom 3 original or BFG edition

Hi all, Doom 3 BFG edition is 75% off and is £4.99 on Steam. However, the original version of Doom 3 is £3.49. I have played Doom 3 in the past but traded it in after I completed it. I want to buy the game again but cannot decide whether the BFG version is worth it or not on PC. 

If your not a mod user than I would say go for it. The graphics/sound are better, it includes the doom 3 expansion, and it also includes doom 1 and 2

DO NOT GET BFG EDITION! THERE IS NO SHADOWS!!!! graphics are also significantly worse

I'd get the original.

Get the original and use the visual mods available. If you dont want to mod get BFG.

get the bfg edition

They both suck really bad...but i prefer the BFG:P

Original and get some mods. 

Wait.... BFG edition doesnt have shadows? WTF... I just bought it. I have the regular edition as well... but I thought the BFG edition was an enhanced version of the original... F_CK ME!

Original and mods no doubt, unless of course the BFG version is WAY cheaper or if you dont use mods.

I'm an idiot but what the hell does BFG stand for?Sweetbackhair

Original + Sikkmod + Wulfen textures.

[QUOTE="Sweetbackhair"]I'm an idiot but what the hell does BFG stand for?Miroku32

they added shadows back into BFG. at launch it didn't have flashlight shadows (maybe some others?) which they allow you to add back on. BFG is better if you play in 3D or you want the 7 extra levels (that I heard are pretty mediocre)nutcrackr

No. You can turn flashlight shadows on and off. im talking about lighting shadows. like lighting in the game. there is only ambient.

Original + Sikkmod + Wulfen textures.

 

 

AMD655

I could never get these to work sadly ;/ or find a site that offers all of the wulfen textures. I could never find a complete set

[QUOTE="nutcrackr"]they added shadows back into BFG. at launch it didn't have flashlight shadows (maybe some others?) which they allow you to add back on. BFG is better if you play in 3D or you want the 7 extra levels (that I heard are pretty mediocre)_SKatEDiRt_

No. You can turn flashlight shadows on and off. im talking about lighting shadows. like lighting in the game. there is only ambient.

Um there are shadows, I think you need to elaborate.

[QUOTE="_SKatEDiRt_"]

[QUOTE="nutcrackr"]they added shadows back into BFG. at launch it didn't have flashlight shadows (maybe some others?) which they allow you to add back on. BFG is better if you play in 3D or you want the 7 extra levels (that I heard are pretty mediocre)way2funny

No. You can turn flashlight shadows on and off. im talking about lighting shadows. like lighting in the game. there is only ambient.

Um there are shadows, I think you need to elaborate.

Everything looks softer and more like the textures in HL1. shadows and lighting arent as apparent or bold. everything seems to be in a fog. And no not because of motion blur. Textures are lower res? Thats what it looks like to me.

[QUOTE="way2funny"]

[QUOTE="_SKatEDiRt_"]

No. You can turn flashlight shadows on and off. im talking about lighting shadows. like lighting in the game. there is only ambient.

_SKatEDiRt_

Um there are shadows, I think you need to elaborate.

Everything looks softer and more like the textures in HL1. shadows and lighting arent as apparent or bold. everything seems to be in a fog.

There is more ambient lighting in BFG yes, The shadows are softer (but they are still volumetric shadows). But to say there are no shadows is rediculous.