Help me choose between a desktop and laptop

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for Whujios
Whujios

62

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#1 Whujios
Member since 2009 • 62 Posts

Hello everyone I go to college in September (just found out I got into MTSU) and anyways I have been looking at Desktops and what not and I can not make up my mind. I want to play games like every valve game, Total War games, Halo, Hitman, and COD 2-5 all at max settings (I'm not the type who can play a modern PC games that looks like **** on a PC, but I tend to play the same games for years at a time)

So my dilemma is whether to buy a Asus Laptop (God I love them they don't overcharge!)or order a good bare bones PC from Compusa and save money by ordering on Tigerdirect and Newegg for the RAM and Graphics card. If I went the Desktop route I would have to buy a new monitor, but I want to keep the cost at 1,000 dollars.

I know the Asus Laptop I have been looking at can play everything I want to play maxed and it would be portable, but then I look at it and I'm like after year or two I won't be able to upgrade. While of course the Desktop would be upgradeable.

Finally have any of you who are college students found having a laptop really that much better than using Desktop at college? Thank you for any responses.
Hello everyone I go to college in September (just found out I got into MTSU) and anyways I have been looking at Desktops and what not and I can not make up my mind. I want to play games like every valve game, Total War games, Halo, Hitman, and COD 2-5 all at max settings (I'm not the type who can play a modern PC games that looks like **** on a PC, but I tend to play the same games for years at a time) So my dilemma is whether to buy a Asus Laptop (God I love them they don't overcharge!)or order a good bare bones PC from Compusa and save money by ordering on Tigerdirect and Newegg for the RAM and Graphics card. If I went the Desktop route I would have to buy a new monitor, but I want to keep the cost at 1,000 dollars. I know the Asus Laptop I have been looking at can play everything I want to play maxed and it would be portable, but then I look at it and I'm like after year or two I won't be able to upgrade. While of course the Desktop would be upgradeable. Finally have any of you who are college students found having a laptop really that much better than using Desktop at college? Thank you for any responses.

Avatar image for chandu83
chandu83

4864

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 44

User Lists: 0

#2 chandu83
Member since 2005 • 4864 Posts
I got to college and from my experience I can tell you having a basic work laptop and a gaming desktop works best for me. You can assemble a fantastic gaming machine for about $800. Mine costed $1100, but I went in for the expensive stuff, and also I got a 24" widescreen monitor. So if you can decrease your configuration just a little bit, you can get some great hardware. So my recommendation is to get a work laptop and a gaming desktop.
Avatar image for True_Sounds
True_Sounds

2915

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 72

User Lists: 0

#3 True_Sounds
Member since 2009 • 2915 Posts

When you get to college you will find that 90% of kids use laptops (at least in my case). They are just so much more practical for the environment you're in. Your gaming will suffer but I was content playing older games on my laptop, and newer ones with the graphics set low. If you buy a desktop you'll be stuck in your room, and you won't be able to study in the lib with friends or bring it into lectures.

Avatar image for umutthejedi
umutthejedi

83

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#4 umutthejedi
Member since 2005 • 83 Posts

I have 2 suggestions

1.A desktop + a netbook

2.A notebook

If you have to be TOO mobile carrying a 3 kg notebook is very hard at long distances. However I'd choose to wait for a few weeks to buy an asus k series with hd4860(40 nm) gpu .

Avatar image for jimmyjammer69
jimmyjammer69

12239

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#5 jimmyjammer69
Member since 2008 • 12239 Posts

I have 2 suggestions

1.A desktop + a netbook

2.A notebook

If you have to be TOO mobile carrying a 3 kg notebook is very hard at long distances. However I'd choose to wait for a few weeks to buy an asus k series with hd4860(40 nm) gpu .

umutthejedi
I second option 1. Once you get to college, you'll probably find that gaming on a laptop between lectures isn't as much fun as you thought it would be thanks to battery life, comfort factors, and the million better things you could be doing in that time. If you do go for a netbook, just check the keybard before buying as some models feel a bit cramped.
Avatar image for 555SSOO
555SSOO

1873

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 137

User Lists: 0

#6 555SSOO
Member since 2008 • 1873 Posts

Desktop.

Avatar image for True_Sounds
True_Sounds

2915

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 72

User Lists: 0

#7 True_Sounds
Member since 2009 • 2915 Posts

[QUOTE="umutthejedi"]

I have 2 suggestions

1.A desktop + a netbook

2.A notebook

If you have to be TOO mobile carrying a 3 kg notebook is very hard at long distances. However I'd choose to wait for a few weeks to buy an asus k series with hd4860(40 nm) gpu .

jimmyjammer69

I second option 1. Once you get to college, you'll probably find that gaming on a laptop between lectures isn't as much fun as you thought it would be thanks to battery life, comfort factors, and the million better things you could be doing in that time. If you do go for a netbook, just check the keybard before buying as some models feel a bit cramped.

If you want to shell out enough money then yeah option 1 works great. If not then decent laptops cost around $500 if you get a good back to school sale in late august. I would not however spend over a a grand on a 'gaming' laptop. Laptops don't live even close to as long desktops can go for. Better to get a cheaper laptop and save your money to eventually invest in building your own desktop.

Avatar image for denter21
denter21

1283

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#8 denter21
Member since 2003 • 1283 Posts
I would get a gaming desktop and not worry about the laptop. In my degree at least, all lectures are posted online afterwards, so there's absolutely no need to bring a laptop to class. Even if they aren't, nobody needs a laptop. Bring a pad of paper and a pen. It's infinitely more comfortable and you can draw diagrams, make changes and add new notes far easier and faster than any word-editing software will allow you to do outside of a tablet pc. Building a desktop lets you upgrade.
Avatar image for bpurk
bpurk

29

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#9 bpurk
Member since 2006 • 29 Posts

dude you should build one, it is much cheaper, you can find great deals on the web......Don't worry if your not sure about how to put one together.....you will learn quick as i did, or if you know a computer geek just ask for a hand.

Avatar image for thekodaman
thekodaman

1733

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#10 thekodaman
Member since 2006 • 1733 Posts
Macbook Pro with educational discount, that is all. Absolutely amazing performance and brilliant for work, only negative is that vista will drain your battery (that lasts over 5 hours on leopard) in the space of 1 hour when running Vista in a display of fantastic OS fail.
Avatar image for artichoke
artichoke

2271

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#11 artichoke
Member since 2006 • 2271 Posts
A decent laptop that will run most modern games shouldn't cost you more than $1000. It won't play Crysis but it'll run pretty much anything else. On my floor of the dorm this year there was only one guy with a desktop and it was a huge disadvantage from him. I took my laptop too class so I could take notes or just mess around. Or take it to the cafeteria to work on homework while getting some food. Also if you need to work on a group project you can take it to the library or a lobby and work on it there. I guess it depends on your college but where I went everybody used their computer outside of their dorm.
Avatar image for gemmanite
gemmanite

25

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#12 gemmanite
Member since 2003 • 25 Posts
At my school, you definitely NEED a laptop. So I would say get either a cheap laptop plus a gaming desktop or just a really nice laptop.